hppants
Well-known member
Yeah - that happened to me on a Honda Accord. When I went to fill up the engine, it POURED onto the driveway. As a matter of practice/habit, I now check the old filter to ensure the gskt came with it.
Bosch 3323 oil filter
- Thread starter glas1/2ful
- Start date
Help Support Yamaha FJR Motorcycle Forum:
glas1/2ful
Well-known member
first - thanks to Ignacio for the clarification of why this went to NEPRT - appreciated.
hppants - thanks for the specific feedback - I probably managed to find 2 culls...
and to the folks that asked about the gasket from the old filter still being there - nope. still on the filter I removed, and I always wipe the loose oil etc before installing a new filter. Being on oh say the cheap side, kept the 2 new 3323 and thinking about swapping the old filter gasket and seeing if I can spring another leak...
hppants - thanks for the specific feedback - I probably managed to find 2 culls...
and to the folks that asked about the gasket from the old filter still being there - nope. still on the filter I removed, and I always wipe the loose oil etc before installing a new filter. Being on oh say the cheap side, kept the 2 new 3323 and thinking about swapping the old filter gasket and seeing if I can spring another leak...
Geezer
Parsimonious Curmudgeon
Well, let's hope it was just a couple of bad ones. Since you got two in a row, it may be a bad batch. Hopefully they will all be off the shelves before spring when I may be looking for one.
glas1/2ful
Well-known member
not to drag this out unnecessarily, but "Mr Observant" here just noticed something this morning - the new filter (on the left in the image) is convex on the top compared to the concave older one on the right
BakerBoy
Well-known member
Good catch on the difference! It also appears that the metal just outward from the threads was bottomed out on your engine's filter mount ... you couldn't have got it on any further.
It would be wise to give Bosch a ring, provide them the manufacturing digits off the filter (or box?) ... they should send you two replacements and recall a buncha filters, my opinion. From their website:
It would be wise to give Bosch a ring, provide them the manufacturing digits off the filter (or box?) ... they should send you two replacements and recall a buncha filters, my opinion. From their website:
Denver_FJR
Well-known member
(Me calling Bosch on phone) "Hello, Bosch? Yeah, I'm using one of your car filters on my motorcycle and it appears you changed the design and it will no longer fit. I think this is a defect and you should initiate a recall, and oh yeah, send me two replacement filters."
<click>
"Hello? Hello?"
<click>
"Hello? Hello?"
BakerBoy
Well-known member
You don't have to say 'motorcycle' 
TomInPA
Well-known member
That design change will affect any vehicle with a flush fitting surface around the filter threads where the bottom of the filter can bottom out before the gasket. Looks like we just lost a compatible filter if they continue the convex bottom surface. That is actually a pretty significant design change.
Pterodactyl
Well-known member
Then what vehicle would you say you have? It is likely to come up in the fruitless callYou don't have to say 'motorcycle'
ionbeam
2 FUN
Almost makes one wonder if the cap wasn't inadvertently installed upside down... (while quality control was sleeping).not to drag this out unnecessarily, but "Mr Observant" here just noticed something this morning - the new filter (on the left in the image) is convex on the top compared to the concave older one on the right
glas1/2ful
Well-known member
Tom - assuming the two new filters aren't just odd mistakes, that would be why I posted originally, altho hppants earlier in this thread had no trouble with a new one
I was thinking of stopping by the store and pulling a new one out of the box to see if it was concave or convex, and if concave, returning the two new ones - it's easy to see (once you see it!)
Old Guy
Well-known member
If it were me, I'd definitely call their warranty support at 855-267-2483 Option 4 and either email them the photo or give them the Photobucket link, Maybe they'd replace the filters and maybe not. But they need to be aware that it no longer works in at least this application. I bet there are others.
Denver_FJR
Well-known member
(Call to Bosch warranty support, 2nd attempt)
"Hello Bosch? Yes, I would like to make you aware that a change you made to one of your oil filters no longer works with my application."
(Charlie Brown adult voice response)
"My application? Well, I don't see why that really matters but I'm attempting to install it on my FJR motorcycle."
(Charlie Brown adult voice response)
"Yes, I understand you never spec'd this filter to work any motorcycle and that the changes made to the filter still allow it to work on those vehicles it was designed for. What you don't understand is it used to work and frankly I think you should recall filters with this new design and reward me with two new filters for pointing this out. I can even provide you with pictures that show how the new design doesn't work on my motorcycle, I mean application."
(Charlie Brown adult voice response)
"What? Did I call earlier? Yes, but you need to understand that I read on the Internet that this filter should work on my motorcycle and everyone agrees you should recall this..."
<click>
"Hello Bosch? Yes, I would like to make you aware that a change you made to one of your oil filters no longer works with my application."
(Charlie Brown adult voice response)
"My application? Well, I don't see why that really matters but I'm attempting to install it on my FJR motorcycle."
(Charlie Brown adult voice response)
"Yes, I understand you never spec'd this filter to work any motorcycle and that the changes made to the filter still allow it to work on those vehicles it was designed for. What you don't understand is it used to work and frankly I think you should recall filters with this new design and reward me with two new filters for pointing this out. I can even provide you with pictures that show how the new design doesn't work on my motorcycle, I mean application."
(Charlie Brown adult voice response)
"What? Did I call earlier? Yes, but you need to understand that I read on the Internet that this filter should work on my motorcycle and everyone agrees you should recall this..."
<click>
Pterodactyl
Well-known member
Scene in the Bosch warranty support office immediately following the <click>
Charlie Brown adult voice guy to fellow cubical farm inhabitants: "I gotta save a copy of this call for the office Christmas party!!!"
Charlie Brown adult voice guy to fellow cubical farm inhabitants: "I gotta save a copy of this call for the office Christmas party!!!"
escapefjrtist
Searching for Dry Roads
Something is very odd with that [new?] Bosch filter. I recently re-stocked my supply from Rock Auto and none are of that design.
For comparison purposes, the new short Yamaha filter plus both short/long Bosch.
--G
For comparison purposes, the new short Yamaha filter plus both short/long Bosch.
--G
glas1/2ful
Well-known member
thanks - [laughing as I type this} your gray box looks like mine {geez...} but the 3323 in this pic besides being concave also has the "old" label - leading credence to maybe me buying two mis-labelled filtersSomething is very odd with that [new?] Bosch filter. I recently re-stocked my supply from Rock Auto and none are of that design.
For comparison purposes, the new short Yamaha filter plus both short/long Bosch.
--G
OldButNotDead (sockpuppet)
Squashed Sockpuppet
Almost makes one wonder if the cap wasn't inadvertently installed upside down... (while quality control was sleeping).not to drag this out unnecessarily, but "Mr Observant" here just noticed something this morning - the new filter (on the left in the image) is convex on the top compared to the concave older one on the right
Kinda looks like ionbeam's theory is supported by escape's evidence. Rather than the skepticism expressed by some about calling Bosch, doncha think they just might be interested in fixing what appears to be a production issue rather than dealing with lawyers and judges?Something is very odd with that [new?] Bosch filter. I recently re-stocked my supply from Rock Auto and none are of that design.
For comparison purposes, the new short Yamaha filter plus both short/long Bosch.
--G
Uncle Hud
Just another blob of protoplasm using up your oxyg
Love this place.
Hilarious phone call "transcriptions" and comparative close-up photos of oil filters. Same topic. Y'all crack me up.
Hilarious phone call "transcriptions" and comparative close-up photos of oil filters. Same topic. Y'all crack me up.
Last edited by a moderator:
Denver_FJR
Well-known member
That is a shrewd observation Dr Ionbeam!Almost makes one wonder if the cap wasn't inadvertently installed upside down... (while quality control was sleeping).
Looking at pics of dissected oil filters, none appear to use a reversible threaded plate.
Maybe someone over-torqued the filter and popped the threaded plate out. Later realizing what they did and returned it to the store!
glas1/2ful
Well-known member
that is exactly my kind of luck... and if so they did it twice and I bought both!
Similar threads
