Echo or Stihl

Yamaha FJR Motorcycle Forum

Help Support Yamaha FJR Motorcycle Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.

Greg 03

Well-known member
Joined
Oct 25, 2012
Messages
241
Reaction score
77
Location
Springfield, MO
Yeah, yeah... I know it's like asking about tires, oil, and ethanol in gas... I'm leaning toward getting an Echo because it seems like Stihl quality has been goin downhill. So everyone pile on and let me know what ya think... Or should I wait until Friday?

 
Honestly don't know much about Echo saws. I do know they are usually sold side by side with Stihls.

We have two Stihls. A 230 and a bigger 330. They are great saws. No quality issues and they are easy to work on. Hell...Get whichever gives you the most saw you need for the money.

 
No Greg that was good. If they don't know what you're talking about they can't have an opinion...And God knows this place is full of opinions. Haha...

 
Zilla pretty much everyone in my extended family has used Stihl for years but within the last year both my father in law and my step dad have had major issues with theirs. One is a high dollar farm boss I think and the other was a mid level homeowner model so it has me a tad leery. Both were replaced with new saws under warranty but the second homeowner saw tanked as well and that's the level I was looking at.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
Well, then it sounds like you answered your own question. Ours are a few years old and run like sumbitches. Patch and I cut 15 cords of wood with them this year.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
I've been trying to kill my Stihl Super 41 since 1978, only thing I've done is wear my self out!

 
Been using Stihl for many years. Only problems have been fuel related. Fresh ethanol free and run it dry when done= no problem.

Current saw is a ms290. Really like it.

 
I've got an Echo, weed eater, leaf blower and chain saw. All have started and run flawlessly for the 5 + years I've owned them.

 
This will not help you but since you asked...

I have two Stihl chainsaws. I have an 024AV with a 16 inch bar bought in the early '80s. It was a German built saw and has been awesome. I have replaced the recoil assembly, that has been the only thing that ever failed. My other Stihl is an MS360Pro with a 25 inch bar. It is about 10 years old and has been flawlessly awesome.

I gave my father-in-law a 16 inch MS210 as a gift. The timing was perfect as Hurricane Katrina hit 2 weeks later. That saw is still running just as well as the two I have.

But... A friend of mine bought an Echo with a 25 inch bar that was very comparable to my MS360Pro. I used it and loved it. The Echo is a high quality piece of equipment and I don't think you will be sorry if you go that route.

You are comparing what is arguably the two best names in chainsaws. If you are worried about quality, step up from the homeowner grade.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
My hand-me-down Stihl 031AV is about 30 years old, but doesn't get the workouts today like it did back on the farm. Runs great when needed though.

A neighbor back in the farm days had an Echo, first one I'd ever seen. He was known for having quality stuff, and his sawr ran as good as the 2 Stihls we had.

The only strong opinion between these two that I have is that whichever one you wind up with, please use the correct name--chainsawr.

coolsmiley02.gif


Shane

 
For the big stuff a Jonsered 2094, smaller stuff Shindaiwa 500 ,for nostalgia well their is Lombard Comango, Titan UG4 gear drive or Homelite 770 or XL12 or 150 or maybe a David Bradley but I really like the Jonsered it just flat out eats !

 
I bought an echo 45 chainsaw this summer. Light, powerful, easy start, good ergos. Build quality right up there, imo. iirc, echo has a longer warranty.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
I have cut 6 cords off my woodlot a year for the last 38 years with the same Homelite Super XL12..still runs like a bear...a torque monster.

 
I run a Stihl 260 PRO to cut 10+ cords of firewood each year. The bigger 361 ( now the 362 ) is more popular around here, and I'll probably add one of those some day, but the 260 is lighter and less tiring for an old geezer like me to cut with for hours at a time. These are both professional grade saws. There is a big difference between the professional line and the homeowner line. Homeowner saws are generally heavier for equal power, and engineered to be replaced over time rather than repaired and kept for many years. So it depends on what you need and how much you want to spend. I believe that Stihl has a great reputation for their professional saws, and they may be using that reputation to market the homeowner line, but they are not the same thing.

The major competitor for Stihl in my neck o' the woods is Husqvarna. The Husky's seem to be comparable in power and reliability, but I never owned one so I can't speak from experience.

I have owned a few homeowner saws over the years, including McCullock, Homelite, and Sear brands. They are all about the same. They run well when new, wear out fast if you work them hard, then end up in the dump. I never owned an Echo.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
Top