The right Sport Touring bike does not exist

Yamaha FJR Motorcycle Forum

Help Support Yamaha FJR Motorcycle Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.

NJ609Eagle

Well-known member
Joined
Apr 7, 2008
Messages
70
Reaction score
0
Location
Cherry Hill, NJ
At 5’2” with a 28” inseam, it’s just about impossible to find the bike that my girlfriend wants. With years of riding experience, and plenty of miles in the saddle, she has tried to find all of the features that she wants in a motorcycle that fits both her size and wallet. Features like Fuel-injections and color-matching hard saddle bags are at the top of the list. Of course there are Givi bags and alike, but that is not the look she really wants. Other would be nice features like a fuel gauge and shaft drive would also be ideal but not deal-breakers. Of course style is a must; it’s got to have some style, but it also has to be in her price range too. We all know that anything is possible with time and money.

Background

For a while she was riding a Yamaha V-Star Classic 750. This was almost the perfect bike for her as she rode it. It had all of the style she wanted minus the color matching hard bags. A very classic motorcycle look with the passing lamps, windshield, leather saddlebags with fringe. Of course being a cruiser, seat height and maneuverability was not an issue. She was easily able to stand up and move her bike around in and out of parking sports. Unfortunately, during one long trip she hit a bump or pothole and caused some serious discomfort with her tailbone. This discomfort became a major problem. Had a custom Cee Bailey’s seat made for her, but no relief was to be found. This eventually put her off the road for a whole riding “season”.

The season after, we went searching high and low for a bike that will allow her to be off of her tailbone while riding. We were able to determine that a standard riding position, or a sport riding position was what she needed to get back on the road. After sitting on many bikes, she was able to settle with the 2008 SV650.

Now this naked bike was not the style she was looking for, but the ability to ride took precedence over style. But even the SV right off the showroom floor was giving her some issues with ride stability. The bike was a little too high only allowing her to have some of the balls of her feet on the ground. A Suzuki Gel seat was bought but that didn’t lower the seat height enough because it was a little wider. Dog Bones to the rescue! And now the bike is manageable at a stop light but still gives her a little apprehension while backing it up, and since we didn’t cut the kickstand, she has a little anxiety when she dismounts the bike. We replaced the bug screen with a larger windshield, added some Cortech textile saddlebags, a Starcom1 unit with iPod, FRS Radio all connected and back on the road loving riding again.

The Search

So now she wants more. Stability on the bike is the first most important thing. So much so that we did demo rides on a trike. It wasn’t the ride she wanted, slow lumbering and big turns were a killer. The fun riding the SV now would be hard to walk away from. One of the first bikes she saw promise in was Honda’s NT700v.

Every feature she was looking for in a bike was there. So we found a dealer with one on the floor so she could check it out. Since the dealers are struggling to sell this bike the price was fairly low. Throw the leg over the bike and reach for the ground. But the ground wasn’t there, only the toes would touch. So we needed to find out what options were available to lower this bike. Did Honda offer a lower Seat option? No. What about a lowering kit? There is one on the market that will take the bike down 1.3 inches. So the dealer and I took off some plastic to make sure it was the right part. Unfortunately it wasn’t. The kit must be for the European model, and the only modification we could see was a shorter spring and maybe lowering the forks. Then we would have to send the seat out to have that trimmed down. Even with the dealer doing some of the modifications, there still wasn’t a warm and fuzzy feeling that she would be able to ride this bike home with comfort hoping for the seat to be the trick. The dealer tried to see if Yamaha’s FJR would fit, but we knew this wouldn’t since that is what I ride. Honda’s ST 1300 wasn’t considered at all because of the price. It also has the same seat issue though.

Leaving the dealer a little bummed, we rode to another dealer close to home. This dealer works with Suzuki, Kawasaki and Honda. I was hoping the parts guy would tell me that the color match bags from the V-Strom 650 would fit her bike, but they didn’t’. While I’m at the counter I turned around and asked her to throw her leg over another bike, Honda’s VFR1200.

She really didn’t want to because the bike looked too big, and the seat looked too high. The VFR1200 seat height is 32.4” compared to the NT700v 31.7”, but she did and WOW! She can touch with more of her foot on this bike than the NT700v. Just shows that the seat height numbers don’t tell the full story. But did the bike have all of the features? Yes it did. Did Honda offer a lower seat? Yes, and they specifically call it a low, narrower seat that will lower the seat height another .8”. With that much lower there probably isn’t a real need to lower the bike anymore, but that option is available with a lowering link. The 1200 gave her a little apprehension being much larger than she currently rides, but I told her that was easy to overcome. Then we get the price on the bike all totaled up with bags and seat changed, it was twice the price of what she wanted to spend. Before we walked out of the dealership we saw the 2008 and 2009 Honda Interceptor. Since it was a leftover, the price points were perfect. The chain-drive was easily overlooked. However, no lower seat option. Too many customizations needed to ride the bike home.

The one last bike we saw was Kawasaki’s Ninja 650R. Sharp bike that is very similar to her SV650. Good upright riding position with the handle bars instead of clip-on controls. It looked like it would fit the bill but there are no color matching hard bags for the bike.

The results

We feel that the manufactures are missing a segment of the market it what they produce, mid-sized sport-touring bike that offers a lower position for shorter legs to reach the ground with a decent price point. Honda almost hit it with the NT700v but they failed to do the right things for the shorter legs. They are close the VFR1200, but the price point is higher. The VFR1200 is a great competitor to the FJR1300 or a sportier ride than the Kawasaki C14. It can even compete with the ST1300 for those who want more sport than touring.

 
You should check out the BMW F650 GS with the low suspension and low seat option. Don't be put off by the enduro looks - it can be an excellent touring bike and has BMW sidebags available for an integrated look. Another option is a BMW R1200R which is more expensive, but in my opinion is worth the extra money. It is also available from BMW in a low suspension configuration.

 
This is a common dilemma for the vertically challenged. Likely you will have to go with a smaller engine and chain drive. The Suzuki Gladius will perhaps surprise you, and you will have to outfit it with bags and a Multi-Vario windshield. No fairings.. Other than that, Yamaha FZ8 Fazer, Honda CB1000F and the like have more upright sitting positions than sport bikes. Buy a good used low miler.

 
Get a Custom seat, you can take a lot of height out of the seat to flat foot on the bike, look for a local guy if not, one there are many shops that you can send your seat to for custom work, We have a local guy here Rich's that that does great work, he has seats come from all around the US to get worked on.

https://www.richscustomseats.com/

 
NJ- very nice write up. You detailed the travails your GF has gone through very nicely. (Not all of us around here are that eluhkw... uh, elockwa.... uh, can write like that.)

Perhaps she could ride the SV for a couple of years until some used VFR's seep into the market? Sounds like the right bike for her but not at the right price, at least for now.

How's her tailbone doing? That just does not sound pleasant at all. A friend of ours wrecked her scooter a few years ago and landed basically in a sitting position. She had an uncomfortably sore tailbone for the better part of a year, and it still bugs her from time to time.

Best of luck to the both of you!

 
Take a glance at the new bike Kawasaki put out. 2011 Ninja 1000. Very upright, hard luggage being built. 32" seat height before working on it. This is a very sporty ride that is a capable tourer.

 
I'm just gonna come out and say it, so don't take it personally...It's just an observation.

I think you may be being a little unreasonable. Even many of us that buy the FJR change things about the bike because it is not perfect for just about anyone. That's why there's so many aftermarket windshields, seats, top cases, risers, highway pegs,paint jobs and farkles in general. Part of the fun is buying what is very close to what we want and making it ours.

Imagine the cost of bikes and the difficulty getting them built and shipped if every bike had every option available for every crazy person that walked in the dealership. Did I want to pay nearly 12K for my bike? Hell no, but was I willing to do it to get what I wanted? Yes. Was I completely happy with the height of the seat? No...I dropped mine once or twice figuring the elevation out, but now, I ride with the seat on the higher setting. I sometimes am able to walk my bike backwards, but when I can't, I stand next to it and push it to where I want it. It's what we all do to make what we have work. Your girlfriend needs to figure out what is absolutely necessary and what is not.

That being said, there are a few options that are very close, but none are perfect according to your above post.

Have you looked at the Suzuki GSX500F or the GSX750F? I don't think I have ever seen a negative review about either one of them, and although they don't come with their own hard bags, lots of luggage is available. They are priced well, not very tall, and are powered well enough for just about anyone.

Another more expensive option is the BMW F800ST. Stock they are a little tall, but BMW can lower them and they come with matching bags and are easy to handle. Being Beemers, they run around 10k new, but they are absolutely fun bikes and may last a lifetime.

I also know people that love the Triumph bikes. The America and I think the Speedster fit some of your requirements, but I'm not sure about the size of the Speedster. The America is an 865 I think and is a cool bike. Both of these are more cruiser than ST. For a more sporty bike, there is the Daytona 675 and the new Street Triple which is just a 675 version of the 1050 Speed Triple. Triumph sells tons of accessories, so any of these may come with bags that the GF likes. It's worth looking.

Eventually, you and her will find the right bike, but I think you may have to be ready for a little more compromise before that will happen.

 
Aw Hell...I forgot the Kawasaki Vulcan 750. I don't even know if they are in production any more, but used ones should be easy to find. They are a 750cc shaft driven bike. They are a cruiser, but have a different shape. I'm sure you have seen them. There are lots of accessories available for them, including saddlebags and slip-on pipes. I have owned two and loved them both. They were a fun bike with a full array of instruments, including a gas gauge...Which is rare in that type of bike.

 
Thank you Everyone for all of your thoughts and opinions.

The idea of aftermarket saddle bags was always a turn off because of how they looked when mounted. Specifically on her SV. They didn't look like they fit properly and stuck out very ugly.

With that being said, and reading in a post elsewhere, apparently the Givi v35 PLX bags, are the same bags used on the Kawasaki Versys. Kawasaki also offers color matching insert panels for the bags. The PLX bags snug up to the tail of the bike, making it look very much like it was factory. While looking at the parts to buy, the TopBox plate and rack are required for teh side bags to be installed. She is not a fan of the top box, well that was until she saw all of the lights that can be added to some of them.

So she is now going back to take a longer look at the Ninja 650r. If she goes with black, it will be the Mini-Me, of my 2008 FJR

 
https://www.cycletrader.com/find/listing/2008-Bmw-F-800-St--98613154 NJ609Eagle, I'm in full agreement with HotRodZilla; with what you're describing in your specifications for a Sport Touring bike for your wife: You're describing a BMW F800ST perfectly. Here's one 750 miles away from you, with only 1,700 miles and only asking $6.9K. Low seat/lowered suspension!

https://azgsgirl.wordpress.com/ FJR Forum Admin SkooterG and I are great friends with AZ Beemers Member Jo Smee. She's 5'-2"/28" inseam.

Jo writes a weekly street/dirt motorcycling column for the local newspapers here in Phoenix, she racks up 10K+ miles a year on her F800ST.

Jo doesn't weigh 100 lbs. wet, but she's always at the front of the pack when we go on an AZ Beemers Club Ride; rides better than SkootyG!

P5080024.jpg


Here is a 5+ minute video review of the BMW F800ST. Bad News: The bloke is riding on the "wrong" side of the bloody road!

Good News: The Narrator speaks English one hell of a lot better than our fine FJR Forum Resident ****** Fairlaner does!

 
Last edited by a moderator:
The idea of aftermarket saddle bags was always a turn off because of how they looked when mounted. Specifically on her SV. They didn't look like they fit properly and stuck out very ugly.
Oh yeah. I had 3 E45 bags on my SV once... I'll not post the pictures so you don't have to claw your eyes out, but it did bring home the groceries, and it did get me to the Honda Hoot and back. I'm a guy though... I don't care how it looks, as long as it functions. I could literally carry an entire shopping-cart-full on that poor little 650.

I *did* get the SW-Motech removable racks. They had HUGE quarter-sized Dzus fasteners, where you unlocked the sidecase racks and all you had was these small thumb size tabs left on the bike. That looked a lot better.

Jo doesn't weigh 100 lbs. wet, but she's always at the front of the pack when we go on an AZ Beemers Club Ride; rides better than SkootyG!
I hope that's not what she rides in... Shorts & t-shirt, and writes a bike column. Srsly?

 
Last edited by a moderator:
Hola Crash Cash, Over here in The Valley of the Blast Furnace, it is standard to wear shorts and a tank top underneath your ATGATT. That way, when you stop, you can immediately cool off when the Aerostich and full coverage helmet are removed. Otherwise, we Zonies would die of heat stroke on a 111F day! Here is Miss Jo in her ATGATT! Chuy sometimes says: To Hell with ATGATT!

P5080029.jpg


 
Last edited by a moderator:
Have you looked at a Triumph Sprint GT It has all your looking for and is a true SportTourer.

Seat hight is 31.5in--- Shave seat with gel insert will give you 1 to 1.5in.

Dog-bones another 3/4 inch. (29 1/4)

Just putting in my two cents.

Jim

 
Paging MaryEllen.... Paging MaryEllen....
Huh? You saying I'm SHORT?! OR....that my azz is fat ?!

Ok, first of all....I'm 5' 4.75" (not 5'2") = huge difference :p

I have nothing to add here. I've pounded 48 000 kms on my links-lowered Feej with the foam cut out of the seat (I wore bicycle shorts under my trousers).

I just got Canucklehead's Corbin and it feels, so far, like my stock seat in height. The Clam Chowdah run will be the first test.

I've practised slow speed maneuvers in parking lots, I've taken both the basic and Experienced Riders courses, and I've ridden in ALL sorts of road and weather conditions (from gravel to snow). And I've dropped it ( a FEW times :D ) but I don't post about it. WTF is THAT about anyway ? :blink:

OVERALL.... I LOVE my Feej and for being such a delicate flower, I think I handle the piggy quite well. And 'no', I'm not PWI :rolleyes:

:lol: Sorry you asked, Robbie?!

 
Paging MaryEllen.... Paging MaryEllen....
Huh? You saying I'm SHORT?! OR....that my azz is fat ?!

Ok, first of all....I'm 5' 4.75" (not 5'2") = huge difference :p

I have nothing to add here. I've pounded 48 000 kms on my links-lowered Feej with the foam cut out of the seat (I wore bicycle shorts under my trousers).

I just got Canucklehead's Corbin and it feels, so far, like my stock seat in height. The Clam Chowdah run will be the first test.

I've practised slow speed maneuvers in parking lots, I've taken both the basic and Experienced Riders courses, and I've ridden in ALL sorts of road and weather conditions (from gravel to snow). And I've dropped it ( a FEW times :D ) but I don't post about it. WTF is THAT about anyway ? :blink:

OVERALL.... I LOVE my Feej and for being such a delicate flower, I think I handle the piggy quite well. And 'no', I'm not PWI :rolleyes:

:lol: Sorry you asked, Robbie?!

You got me all wrong MaryEllen.

My thoughts were that you are the poster girl for FJR. The Original poster was saying his GF was too short. I beg to differ. Even at 5'4.75" your legs are probably longer than mine. I have a 29' inseam. I have to tippy toe around or get off and push. I think you handle the bike very well. I was hoping you would pipe in and say go for it.

(PWI)???

Rob

 
Paging MaryEllen.... Paging MaryEllen....
Huh? You saying I'm SHORT?! OR....that my azz is fat ?!

Ok, first of all....I'm 5' 4.75" (not 5'2") = huge difference :p

I have nothing to add here. I've pounded 48 000 kms on my links-lowered Feej with the foam cut out of the seat (I wore bicycle shorts under my trousers).

I just got Canucklehead's Corbin and it feels, so far, like my stock seat in height. The Clam Chowdah run will be the first test.

I've practised slow speed maneuvers in parking lots, I've taken both the basic and Experienced Riders courses, and I've ridden in ALL sorts of road and weather conditions (from gravel to snow). And I've dropped it ( a FEW times :D ) but I don't post about it. WTF is THAT about anyway ? :blink:

OVERALL.... I LOVE my Feej and for being such a delicate flower, I think I handle the piggy quite well. And 'no', I'm not PWI :rolleyes:

:lol: Sorry you asked, Robbie?!

You got me all wrong MaryEllen.

My thoughts were that you are the poster girl for FJR. The Original poster was saying his GF was too short. I beg to differ. Even at 5'4.75" your legs are probably longer than mine. I have a 29' inseam. I have to tippy toe around or get off and push. I think you handle the bike very well. I was hoping you would pipe in and say go for it.

(PWI)???

Rob
Oh, DUH. Sorry !

I don't know what my inseam is but my legs are pretty slim so not having that extra flesh helps me reach the ground - same principle as having less saddle material right? I'm still tiptoeing and have to very careful about where and how I stop.

It annoys the hell out of me that you short-ish guys can not only wheel the Feej around but you can take passengers ! And it's because you have the extra strength that I don't have (and I work out!)

With me, it's a fine balancing act and I've achieved a happy truce with my Feej. I've promised her that I don't have a dropsy this year, she'll get a new paint job :D

So, "go for it" to the OP? um......at our height - or lack thereof - 2" is significant. I sat on a Wee-strom the other day at the dealer's and I figure that with that bike lowered a wee bit (or maybe not), the 200 or so fewer pounds makes THAT a viable bike for me. And it can be beautifully equipped for LD riding. She may want to consider that one (can't remember if that was discussed or not)

I was being a bit silly in my post, Rob (PWI - posting while intoxicated??). Thank you for the poster-girl observation :blush:

 
At 5’2” with a 28” inseam, it’s just about impossible to find the bike that my girlfriend wants. With years of riding experience, and plenty of miles in the saddle, she has tried to find all of the features that she wants in a motorcycle that fits both her size and wallet. Features like Fuel-injections and color-matching hard saddle bags are at the top of the list. Of course there are Givi bags and alike, but that is not the look she really wants. Other would be nice features like a fuel gauge and shaft drive would also be ideal but not deal-breakers. Of course style is a must; it’s got to have some style, but it also has to be in her price range too. We all know that anything is possible with time and money.

Background

For a while she was riding a Yamaha V-Star Classic 750. This was almost the perfect bike for her as she rode it. It had all of the style she wanted minus the color matching hard bags. A very classic motorcycle look with the passing lamps, windshield, leather saddlebags with fringe. Of course being a cruiser, seat height and maneuverability was not an issue. She was easily able to stand up and move her bike around in and out of parking sports. Unfortunately, during one long trip she hit a bump or pothole and caused some serious discomfort with her tailbone. This discomfort became a major problem. Had a custom Cee Bailey’s seat made for her, but no relief was to be found. This eventually put her off the road for a whole riding “season”.

The season after, we went searching high and low for a bike that will allow her to be off of her tailbone while riding. We were able to determine that a standard riding position, or a sport riding position was what she needed to get back on the road. After sitting on many bikes, she was able to settle with the 2008 SV650.

Now this naked bike was not the style she was looking for, but the ability to ride took precedence over style. But even the SV right off the showroom floor was giving her some issues with ride stability. The bike was a little too high only allowing her to have some of the balls of her feet on the ground. A Suzuki Gel seat was bought but that didn’t lower the seat height enough because it was a little wider. Dog Bones to the rescue! And now the bike is manageable at a stop light but still gives her a little apprehension while backing it up, and since we didn’t cut the kickstand, she has a little anxiety when she dismounts the bike. We replaced the bug screen with a larger windshield, added some Cortech textile saddlebags, a Starcom1 unit with iPod, FRS Radio all connected and back on the road loving riding again.

The Search

So now she wants more. Stability on the bike is the first most important thing. So much so that we did demo rides on a trike. It wasn’t the ride she wanted, slow lumbering and big turns were a killer. The fun riding the SV now would be hard to walk away from. One of the first bikes she saw promise in was Honda’s NT700v.

Every feature she was looking for in a bike was there. So we found a dealer with one on the floor so she could check it out. Since the dealers are struggling to sell this bike the price was fairly low. Throw the leg over the bike and reach for the ground. But the ground wasn’t there, only the toes would touch. So we needed to find out what options were available to lower this bike. Did Honda offer a lower Seat option? No. What about a lowering kit? There is one on the market that will take the bike down 1.3 inches. So the dealer and I took off some plastic to make sure it was the right part. Unfortunately it wasn’t. The kit must be for the European model, and the only modification we could see was a shorter spring and maybe lowering the forks. Then we would have to send the seat out to have that trimmed down. Even with the dealer doing some of the modifications, there still wasn’t a warm and fuzzy feeling that she would be able to ride this bike home with comfort hoping for the seat to be the trick. The dealer tried to see if Yamaha’s FJR would fit, but we knew this wouldn’t since that is what I ride. Honda’s ST 1300 wasn’t considered at all because of the price. It also has the same seat issue though.

Leaving the dealer a little bummed, we rode to another dealer close to home. This dealer works with Suzuki, Kawasaki and Honda. I was hoping the parts guy would tell me that the color match bags from the V-Strom 650 would fit her bike, but they didn’t’. While I’m at the counter I turned around and asked her to throw her leg over another bike, Honda’s VFR1200.

She really didn’t want to because the bike looked too big, and the seat looked too high. The VFR1200 seat height is 32.4” compared to the NT700v 31.7”, but she did and WOW! She can touch with more of her foot on this bike than the NT700v. Just shows that the seat height numbers don’t tell the full story. But did the bike have all of the features? Yes it did. Did Honda offer a lower seat? Yes, and they specifically call it a low, narrower seat that will lower the seat height another .8”. With that much lower there probably isn’t a real need to lower the bike anymore, but that option is available with a lowering link. The 1200 gave her a little apprehension being much larger than she currently rides, but I told her that was easy to overcome. Then we get the price on the bike all totaled up with bags and seat changed, it was twice the price of what she wanted to spend. Before we walked out of the dealership we saw the 2008 and 2009 Honda Interceptor. Since it was a leftover, the price points were perfect. The chain-drive was easily overlooked. However, no lower seat option. Too many customizations needed to ride the bike home.

The one last bike we saw was Kawasaki’s Ninja 650R. Sharp bike that is very similar to her SV650. Good upright riding position with the handle bars instead of clip-on controls. It looked like it would fit the bill but there are no color matching hard bags for the bike.

The results

We feel that the manufactures are missing a segment of the market it what they produce, mid-sized sport-touring bike that offers a lower position for shorter legs to reach the ground with a decent price point. Honda almost hit it with the NT700v but they failed to do the right things for the shorter legs. They are close the VFR1200, but the price point is higher. The VFR1200 is a great competitor to the FJR1300 or a sportier ride than the Kawasaki C14. It can even compete with the ST1300 for those who want more sport than touring.
I hate to speak like a heretic, but have you considered some of the new model scooters? Certainly not the same style as our preferred "boiler between the legs" rides, but some of them make plenty of speed for highway cruising, step-through which makes seat height pretty much a non-issue, and even high-tech models like the Piaggio three-wheeler.

 
Hola Crash Cash, Over here in The Valley of the Blast Furnace, it is standard to wear shorts and a tank top underneath your ATGATT.
And that's why I've decided to skip the visit to Arizona in the middle of the summer! Plus I've now had the pleasure of reading her blog and realize she is serious about things.

More on topic, Micapeak used to have a really good short-bikes list, but that was back in the Ninja 900 years unfortunately. ISAGN.

 
Top