What Generation are 2016 and 2017 FJRs? (Run-Off)

Ignacio · Jul 7, 2017

With a plurality of votes we need to have a run-off of the top two vote-getters (Gen 3.5 or Gen 4) on what to call the 2016 and 2017 FJRs. This is a new vote, so please vote for a final time.

Poll results will be tallied Friday, July 28, 2017 and I'll update the designator accordingly on the FJR year choice we each have on the left.

Be forewarned that off-topic posts that aren't directly focused on subject-at-hand will be toasted. Please...stick...to...the...subject. Thank you for your contributions to the FJR community.

escapefjrtist · Jul 8, 2017

Vote cast...looking forward to the results (

) and subsequent forum banter!

--G

07FJRVegas · Jul 8, 2017

I read all the comments from the previous vote; many good points made for the different options provided on that vote. For me it boils down to consistency and not favoring commencing the use of a decimal. For this simple reason, I voted Gen 4.

Mihalis fjr · Jul 8, 2017

Well,in Europe we say:

01-02 /03 US No Abs: Gen1

03-05 /04-05 US Abs or no Abs: Gen2

06-12: Gen3

2013-2017: Gen4

As about the 03 Abs or not is a little confusion here,probably never came in US.It is the same with the 04-05 but the color on the handlebars and the triple yoke is the same with the 01-02 European/03 US Light silver,not the dark metal silver as the 04-05 is.Also the color of the rims is light silver,not the same with the 04-05.On the 04-05 the color of the rims is a bit darker.Also finaly has the Yamaha logo sticker on the side plastics under the seat..

Perhaps you don't know about these differences...

Here how the 03 European model looks:

https://cdn.yamaha-motor.eu/design-cafe/2003/FJR1300A-STUDIO%20PS02.jpg

Also in Europe came and in this light green color:

https://cdn.yamaha-motor.eu/design-cafe/2004/FJR1300-STUDIO-01%20PS01.jpg

https://www.yamaha-motor.eu/designcafe/en/about-bikes/sport-touring/index.aspx?view=article&id=442654&segment=&archive=false&page=1

Ignacio · Jul 8, 2017

Mihalis fjr said:
Perhaps you don't know about these differences...

I do, but it's not really relevant here. Discussed before in the linked thread. I thought it was marketing hooey mostly personally.

Regardless, feel free to vote. That's what's going to matter in this poll and thread.

Thanks.

GrayDog37 · Jul 8, 2017

Good poll! Gearbox, clutch, and light changes are significant to me as a rider. I have a Gen 2 and love it. But, if I purchase another, I'll look for a 2016 or newer for these features. So, I think these changes deserve a full number change. Gen 4 is my vote.

rbentnail · Jul 8, 2017

Plurality of votes my ***, did you not get the answer you wanted?

Decimal points suck, Gen4.

Ignacio · Jul 8, 2017

rbentnail said:
Plurality of votes my ***, did you not get the answer you wanted?
Decimal points suck, Gen4.

Why the attitude dude?

47.96% is less than 50% plus one vote. That's a plurality, plain and simple. As stated consistently from the very beginning, a run-off would decide if a majority wasn't established. If I could have done ranked choice voting in one round via the poll mechanism I would have, but couldn't make it work that way.

It doesn't matter what I want or what you want. If it was about what I want I'd just call it Gen 3.5 and not do a poll. This one is going to be forum majority and current trends are aiming towards Gen 4. Fine with me however it turns out.

So, go vote! We'll know the results soon enough.

Fred W · Jul 9, 2017

The poll should be Gen 3 vs Gen 4. A vote for 3.5 was a vote for Gen 3.

Ignacio · Jul 9, 2017

Fred W said:
The poll should be Gen 3 vs Gen 4. A vote for 3.5 was a vote for Gen 3.

Or a 3 vote could have been a vote for 3.5....

Gen 3 was included in the first poll and received the third most votes at 18.37%. Gen 3.5 received the second most amount of votes at 28.57%.

It certainly wouldn't make sense to run off #1 with #3....so we're going two a run-off since #1 and #2 didn't get a majority. Basic voting stuff here.

eflyguy · Jul 9, 2017

Gen IV sounds a lot better than Gen III.V..

I think the mechanical changes are enough to justify a new Gen.

Fred W · Jul 9, 2017

Ignacio said:
Fred W said:

The poll should be Gen 3 vs Gen 4. A vote for 3.5 was a vote for Gen 3.

Click to expand...

Or a 3 vote could have been a vote for 3.5....
Gen 3 was included in the first poll and received the third most votes at 18.37%. Gen 3.5 received the second most amount of votes at 28.57%.

It certainly wouldn't make sense to run off #1 with #3....so we're going two a run-off since #1 and #2 didn't get a majority. Basic voting stuff here.

Yes basic, except the original poll was flawed since there was no Gen 4.5. The voting was skewed. The Gen 4 choice collected all Gen 4 votes vs the Gen 3 was divided between 3 and 3.5. A vote for Gen 3.5 was also a vote for Gen 3, just updated. The original poll was the equivalent of putting one candidate from 4G party on the ballot against two candidates from the 3G party

The base question should have been: Are these bikes stil 3rd Gens, or are they deserving of a new Generation?

Honestly, I don't care that much what they get called. I'm just pointing out the inequity of the process.

Ignacio · Jul 9, 2017

Fred W said:
The base question should have been: Are these bikes stil 3rd Gens, or are they deserving of a new Generation?

I never remember 4.5 even being really considered. You have a source for that conversation?

Regardless, you should go do a poll however you want then!

Fred W · Jul 9, 2017

Ok I'll do that. It should be interesting to see if the results are any different when asked differently.

Warchild · Jul 10, 2017

See, our bike is so perfect in so many ways, we are reduced to talking about superfluous model differences/designations.

My 2013 is the first year GenIII FJR1300, without question or controversy.

The only real item I wish I had (that 2014+ bikes do have) is an unhindered cruise control.

The first year Gen III factory cruise control is restricted to 80mph. It's a software limitation, and 10-15 years ago, I would not put up with this; I would had contacted my sources in the Technical Division in Cypress and find out what black box module I need to swap out with a 2014 or later equivalent, and get 'er done.

But, I haven't bothered. It's not that age has finally softened me (I don't think), rather, nowadays the FJR is a permanently 2-up touring machine for Annie and I, and the fact of the matter is: there is little need to blast around at supra-legals speeds for long periods when I am carrying her.

If I want to enter the realm of being a scofflaw, I'll be on the Hayabusa.

Hammer Down Brown · Jul 10, 2017

No good deed should go unpunished.

BkerChuck · Jul 10, 2017

Vote cast.

Conflicted though as I can see both sides of the argument. Let the majority rule and let's move on.

st4sal · Jul 16, 2017

Warchild said:
See, our bike is so perfect in so many ways, we are reduced to talking about superfluous model differences/designations.

My 2013 is the first year GenIII FJR1300, without question or controversy.

The only real item I wish I had (that 2014+ bikes do have) is an unhindered cruise control.

The first year Gen III factory cruise control is restricted to 80mph. It's a software limitation, and 10-15 years ago, I would not put up with this; I would had contacted my sources in the Technical Division in Cypress and find out what black box module I need to swap out with a 2014 or later equivalent, and get 'er done.

But, I haven't bothered. It's not that age has finally softened me (I don't think), rather, nowadays the FJR is a permanently 2-up touring machine for Annie and I, and the fact of the matter is: there is little need to blast around at supra-legals speeds for long periods when I am carrying her.

If I want to enter the realm of being a scofflaw, I'll be on the Hayabusa.

Kind of funny How my riding "slows sown" when my wife is on the back...

I was seriously considering a 16/17 but Reno John Made me reconsider//

K_Flyer · Jul 23, 2017

Who cares? I certainly do not! No vote cast.

What Generation are 2016 and 2017 FJRs? (Run-Off)

Help Support Yamaha FJR Motorcycle Forum:

What Generation are 2016 and 2017 FJRs?

Gen 3.5

Gen 4

Intramural Culture Warrior

Searching for Dry Roads

Well-known member

Well-known member

Intramural Culture Warrior

Member

Economic Plankton

Intramural Culture Warrior

1 Wheel Drive

Intramural Culture Warrior

Well-known member

1 Wheel Drive

Intramural Culture Warrior

1 Wheel Drive

Benevolent Dictator

Well-known member

Second hand vegetarian

Active member

Well-known member

Similar threads