I don't know if its the same part, however I have a spare from an '06 (cobalt blue). It's in good shape with light scratches, however I suspect you'd want to prime & repaint it to match your '05 (Galaxy blue). Perhaps Garauld would repaint a fender for less than a side case lid ($80).
PM me with your email address & I'll send hi-rez photos of the fender.
I have got a brand new one, not sure what shipping would be, going to deals gap at of month, might could meet you some where, call me Todd 386-673-6028