Great write up with interesting discoveries.
Since the damping is accomplished by the oil passing through valve orifices, changing the oil wt. can sometimes be enough to suit ones needs even without changing springs. With stock valving though, you can't stray too far from stock oil wt. or the adjustments won't be able to compensate enough to maintain a suitable ride.
I read a fork oil comparison someplace where they found the same wt. of oil of different brands varied quite a bit from each other. So even the brand of oil throws in some more variables now.
The idea of a progressive spring seems to make sense (more compliant over small road irregularities) but the theory doesn't often seem to work in all applications.
Since the damping is accomplished by the oil passing through valve orifices, changing the oil wt. can sometimes be enough to suit ones needs even without changing springs. With stock valving though, you can't stray too far from stock oil wt. or the adjustments won't be able to compensate enough to maintain a suitable ride.
I read a fork oil comparison someplace where they found the same wt. of oil of different brands varied quite a bit from each other. So even the brand of oil throws in some more variables now.
The idea of a progressive spring seems to make sense (more compliant over small road irregularities) but the theory doesn't often seem to work in all applications.