I have an '06 AE and an '07 VStar 1300. Comparing the two when driving in Houston traffic is comparing sitting on a beach on Maui and shoveling sand on that same beach. I will continue to put the AE at the top of my list when considering a replacement, though I am not considering replacing the bike I have now.
I still think the AE owners are the leading edge of the future. BRP is bringing the clutch-leverless CanAm spyder to the market, though it is really a centrifugal clutch rather than the electronic control of the AE. There are continuing rumors of either a semi or full automatic Gold Wing. Look at how many peoplle could be added to the riding fraternity if they did not have full manual clutch system we had always had. My wife never learned to drive a manual trans car. When she took the MSF course working a clutch was her biggest challenge.
The negative publicity the AE received from the press has not swayed me at all. Yamaha went out on a limb to bring the AE to the market and was promptly slapped by the press who were intent on looking for anything negative they could dream up. Those of us who have many thousands of miles on our AEs can tell you the press incorrect in their judgment. No bike is perfect, not even the AE, but it's pretty damn good and I don't for a minute regret choosing the AE over the A.
But that's just my opinion, I could be wrong!! :bike: