I was keeping my eyes open for a Valkyrie in 2006 when I came across my FJR. I was looking for a replacement for my aging 1979 XS Eleven Special. I'm really not a cruiser guy, I put low bars on the XS so it was more like a standard. Nobody was making the kind of bike I was looking for in '06. I wanted 4 cylinders, shaft drive and no bodywork. I found out I could only get 2 out of 3. The salespeople at the bike shops would show me bikes like the Kawasaki Z1000, Yamaha FZ1, etc which all had chain drive. I told them I had to have a shaft and they would show me the v-twin cruisers. Althought the Valkyrie has 6 cylinders it has all the other requirements, and decent ergonomics (not feet forward).
I never regretted getting the FJR. It's a great bike and does what I want it to do very well. As for the Valkyrie, I wanted a bike that was good for taking a passenger. I'm extra careful when I've got a passenger and it bothers me when I ride the FJR way too far within its limits, if that makes any sense.