Fun With Physics--A-Bombs, Black Holes, and Hawking

Yamaha FJR Motorcycle Forum

Help Support Yamaha FJR Motorcycle Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.

James Burleigh

Well-known member
Joined
Dec 16, 2006
Messages
3,170
Reaction score
162
Location
San Francisco Bay Area
Last night I was in Berkeley for a recruiting function and had the chance to meet my son, A~, the physics major for dinner. As usual, we talked about physics, which is really cool stuff. For example last night we were talking about how, at about 4 am just before they pulled the trigger on the first test of the A-Bomb at Los Alamos in 1945, one of the physicists said, "Um, I wonder if we should call the governor of New Mexico just to let him know we're going to make a pretty big bang, and that we might accidentally ignite the atmosphere and incinerate the state...?" :eek:

Then A~ tells me about a similar situation of a potential catastrophic outcome with this new super-colider they're building. Apparently it will certainly create mini singularities (black holes). Those won't be a problem. But there's also a possibility, albeit a very small one, that it might create a black hole that will destroy the planet. :glare: So there are people against building it.

I asked A~ what the probability was, and he said something like, "It's about one chance in one to the negative 40." I asked what that looked like. He stared off into the distance for a few seconds, then said something to the effect of, "It's has about one chance in 40 million billion, billion, billion of happening." I chuckled and said we bet our lives every day on greater probabilities (for example, of being killed in a car--not motorcycle :no2: --accident). So we left it that they should build it because it would be cool, and that the folks against it should play the lottery, because they'll feel they have a good chance of winning.

And speaking of physics and Berkeley, it seems Steven Hawking spoke to two paying, sold-out crowds on campus this week. But what was cool was that A~ got to attend the private presentation he made only to students and faculty in physics and astronomy. Although A~ didn't get to meet Hawking, he said he was almost run over by him as he was leaving Le Conte Hall after the presentation. My son commented, "He moves pretty fast in that wheel chair!"

To listen to the public presentation, go here.

hawking.jpg


 
Last edited by a moderator:
Tell your son if I feel my atoms being pulled apart by the black hole created by his super collider, I'm really gonna be pissed! :dribble: Oh, maybe they could kinda fire it up near the IRS? :lol: Cool story, BTW.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
Why A~? Is that Al, Alvin, Astroman, Abe or what?

Is he famous?

Oh and tell us when they plan to start it up - I want to be pointed into it to see how fast I can go.

Bruce

 
Please keep all super colliders away from me, had all the collisons I need thanks :D Nice story, I could chat with him for hours. I read Hawkings book, understood some of it as well!!!

 
I love discussing Physics...we know so little and there's just so much more to learn and experience! I understand almost none of it, but I sure can come up with some questions and off the wall theories! Best of luck to your son. If they do blow up the galaxy, I hope I'm riding when it happens.

 
Food for thought...The other day there was a thread about a guy that didn't like the blinking of the clock on the gauge display. I was thinking about it from a physics perspective, that using the theory of relativity, if you could ride your bike fast enough, could you get the blinking to stop. If beyond that point you could accelerate, would it start blinking backwards. Something to think about next time you go though some really tight turns.... Rich

 
Oooh, now I suffer from symptomatic SuperCollideritis. For that, the government owes me 1 billion billion dollars for stress, agony, and loss of sleep. Either that, or the gumnnt needs to recognize the super collider is just waaay to dangerous to build. Now, I got to go to my second job of working at the local nuclear power plant.. :rolleyes: Great post JB, made me grin.

 
Food for thought...The other day there was a thread about a guy that didn't like the blinking of the clock on the gauge display. I was thinking about it from a physics perspective, that using the theory of relativity, if you could ride your bike fast enough, could you get the blinking to stop. If beyond that point you could accelerate, would it start blinking backwards. Something to think about next time you go though some really tight turns.... Rich

The clock blinks?

;)

Now if someone would just set off a nuke inside a black hole. Hell, I just want to see what happens....

 
...Now if someone would just set off a nuke inside a black hole. Hell, I just want to see what happens....
You can see inside a black hole? - no jokes - too easy- I thought the whole idea of a black hole was that there was so much gravity associated with it that nothing - not even light - escapes.

 
Next time you visit A~, ask him to explain String Theory to you in very simple terms.

Simple terms- basic constituents of matter are vibrating closed and open loop strings 10-43m long instead of point like masses. BTW, Hawkings is largely hype these days. For those of you who are interested, the best layman's book on Physis is Brian Greene, "The Fabric of the Cosmos". He is a Rhodes Scholar, finalist for Nobel, ect. Damn good read too. Beats the hell out of Hawkins book.

JB- I think even your son would like it. I know when I went to school for physics that I lost the comprehensive view this book teaches.

 
You can see inside a black hole? - no jokes - too easy- I thought the whole idea of a black hole was that there was so much gravity associated with it that nothing - not even light - escapes.
No, no, no. I want to see what happens, not see into the black hole. Some might theroize that if the singularity was small enough, and the thermonucular explosion large enough, something interesting might occur externally to the black hole. You might not necessarily see the actual reaction, only the resulting effects from it.

Hey, I have this box with a cat in it, but I don't want to look inside to see if it's dead yet because the act of looking could alter the results. ;) :lol:

 
After watching the video of the Hawking presentation at UC Berkeley, it seemed sort of superficial in that it covered topics in a general way without much factual backup. Of couse the first third of the presentation was UC Berkeley staff getting their 5 minutes of fame. Thanks for the reference for 'The Fabric of the Cosmos', I'll see if ABEBooks.com can get it for me cheaply...

 
Top