Cycleport mesh gear for me. Proven it's worth. Since upgraded to quad armor that I, obviously, hope never to test. Fellow Michelin-men unite!
I was wearing my Held Phanotm gloves at the time of my get-off so I did not get to test the Cycleport Keprotech gloves that I also ride with frequently. Helds were wonderful and the palm of one got chewed up enough to convinced me that my hand would have been torn up without the protection. The Cycleport gloves are not waterproof but they dry quickly so for rain when it's not cold they are great. I, too, am considering the Aerostitch three fingered overgloves for those cold, wet days (I figure that if I buy 'em then I will never need 'em).
Back to the original question: Boots proven in a get-off? Daytona, Daytona, Daytona. Comfortable, Gore-tex lined, well armoured. At 35 mph no visbile damage to footwear, and no contusions, lacerations, incisions or any other unwanted skin/bone/muscle-affecting events. Now, if I could just break myself of the sole-surfing habit that I picked up when following TJB then the bottoms would last a while longer.