Powercommander and Barbarian mod do the same thing. Doing both it just redundant. If the Powercommander didn't cure it then you were not running a good map.
Well, not quite. The Barbarian Mod and raising the CO will add fuel primarily at idle, with a decreasing effect as the throttle is opened (but it will still be richer)
The Power Commander you can program the individual "Throttle vs. RPM" cells and add fuel just where it is needed, and actually decrease fueling where it is already too rich. And yes, there
are areas of the stock FI map whee it is too rich, generally speaking it is with larger throttle openings at lower rpms.
Most of the maps I have ever seen for the PCIII, with an exception being the Wally map, have zeroes in the entire "zero throttle" column (more on the Wally map later). So the CO setting
would be adding fuel somewhere that the PCIII map isn't.
The primary root cause for the off throttle to on throttle transition jerkiness is that on trailing throttle conditions the ECU
cuts all fuel from the injectors until the rpms drop down to near idle, and then it only adds enough to maintain idle. This is what makes fuel injected bikes have such strong engine braking characteristics as compared to carburetted bikes. Then when you crack the throttle back open it suddenly begins to add fuel at the normal rate and there is suddenly ignition in the cylinder and some power being made... Jerk!
The Wally "smoothness" map does add 10% at zero throttle but only at 1500 rpm. Since nobody actually rides around at 1500 rpm, that cell is essentially useless. Not sure what the reasoning was for him putting a 10 there. Actually, I'm not sure that anything that you enter in the 0 throttle column has any effect in overriding the ECU's fuel cut on trailing throttle programming.
The way that the smoothness map helps at all is by added some fuel in the 2% column to soften the blow, but the Wally map only does this at 1500 - 2500 rpm. Wally must have ridden his FJR considerably differently from me. I don't know about you, but when I come railing into a corner and chop the throttle to reduce entry speed, then roll back on as entering the corner, my rpm is generally in the 2500- 5000 rpm range. So a Wally map should not do a thing for me. And it doesn't, so I don't use it.
The map that I have and use adds fuel all the way down the 2% throttle column from just above idle up to 4500 rpm and in the 5% throttle column up to redline. It gives considerably smoother transitions than the Wally map did. I'd still like to get a custom map for my bike to improve the gas mileage a bit, but this map is the smoothest I have tried.
Here's a
link to the map, in case anyone wants to try it or have a look at it. Note: It is is a first Gen map and would probably need some translation to work on a second gen.