Brings back memories...
My kid got his first vehicle at age 16 - a 1987 Toyota pickup with 150K on the clock or so, not too much rust, $1,100. Yep, he dented the hell out of it learning. We sold that to my brother-in-law two years later, 12 years ago, and BIL is still driving it with 350K or something on it. But I remember The Boy, when he was driving his increasingly dented beater, noting all his buddies who were driving brand new rigs. I just pointed at his dents and said "no way." Later, I bought another beater and let him "borrow" it. He totalled that one. Since then he's been buying and maintaining his own vehicles. Amazing how much better they hold up and how much longer they last. So, Pants and Tootie are doing this right: Make her earn the equity. Give her the responsibility...and pride in ownership. That increases the owner's value multi-fold. But, oh, her heart will break when she gets that first scratch, parking lot dimple or dent.