If I were going to get an aftermarket bolt for this purpose, I would be looking at aircraft quality. These typically have a guaranteed rolled thread and excellent quality control (excellently uniform strength). Metric grade 12.9 would be what I'd want to find.
You could probably get away with a lower grade, say 10.9, but the cost for a few bolts is so small in the grand scheme of things, that I would just go for the high end.
You could contact the manufacturer and ask them to send you a couple of bolts. They might do it for free, or at least for a modest charge. The shipping will probably be comparable to the price of the bolts.
As Ignacio said though, if they haven't been overtorqued, you should be able to reuse them. If they've been grossly over torqued, you could probably see it in thread deformation.
Its not a bad idea to call the manufacturer and ask for their advice. You could get some free bolts out of the call.