@Redfish Hunter
@Redfish Hunter
I seriously tried a whole bunch of different seats on the 2005 when I first got it before I got a Russell. Here's the run down:
The 1 year old bike bike came with a Corbin Canyon close
I traded that with another (shorter) guy for the Canyon "normal" as I am not vertically challenged.
I bought a set of the stock seats and tried those
I sent the stock seats to a guy in North Dakota (called himself Kno-Place) to be customized with gel and memory foam inserts
I bought a Corbin Modular (just the front) that had been ordered customized by the prior owner. It had heat.
I bought a used Rick Mayer Dual with vinyl cover. That was the closest I'd come to comfort and what convinced me that I needed to try a Russell customized to me. All of the above were tried with different mitigating solutions of seat padding, wearing bicycle shorts, etc.
Finally I took the front seat (that had already been modified by Kno-Place) and had it Russellized with the rear portion just recovered in leather to match. (They sent me the Gel and Foam inserts back when they returned the new custom seat.) Even that was a mistake as once I realized that the Russell IS all that and a bag of chips, I had to buy another stock rear seat and send that off to be Russellized for my missus. I kept the recovered KnoPlace rear seat as it does look nicer for when mi'lady is not along.
So you see... just plonking down the cash up front is actually a far more frugal path than I went down previously.
@David Foley
@David Foley
@charleetho
It's actually a phrase that I picked up here on this forum, from fellow member Haulin' (Jeff) Ashe talking about some 4'12" pole dancer he likes to visit, and Jeff lives down south. I like to pull it out every now and then since it applies so well to to my wife. It always does seem to get a little reaction from folks...That New England measuring tape must be different from the ones we use Down South. 4'12" sounds a whole lot like 5' to me.
@Redfish Hunter
See, it only appears that I'm not being frugal. In actuality, I learned the hard way that you can spend a whole lot of time and money dicking around with various partial solutions, but then in the end still have to shell out the money for the custom seat to be truly comfortable.Fred, I am shocked and proud at the same time. You don't sound like a Frugal Yankee here lately. I 100% agree with spending the money to buy happiness. If you know it works and you know it is worth it, spend the money.
I seriously tried a whole bunch of different seats on the 2005 when I first got it before I got a Russell. Here's the run down:
The 1 year old bike bike came with a Corbin Canyon close
I traded that with another (shorter) guy for the Canyon "normal" as I am not vertically challenged.
I bought a set of the stock seats and tried those
I sent the stock seats to a guy in North Dakota (called himself Kno-Place) to be customized with gel and memory foam inserts
I bought a Corbin Modular (just the front) that had been ordered customized by the prior owner. It had heat.
I bought a used Rick Mayer Dual with vinyl cover. That was the closest I'd come to comfort and what convinced me that I needed to try a Russell customized to me. All of the above were tried with different mitigating solutions of seat padding, wearing bicycle shorts, etc.
Finally I took the front seat (that had already been modified by Kno-Place) and had it Russellized with the rear portion just recovered in leather to match. (They sent me the Gel and Foam inserts back when they returned the new custom seat.) Even that was a mistake as once I realized that the Russell IS all that and a bag of chips, I had to buy another stock rear seat and send that off to be Russellized for my missus. I kept the recovered KnoPlace rear seat as it does look nicer for when mi'lady is not along.
So you see... just plonking down the cash up front is actually a far more frugal path than I went down previously.
@David Foley
It has been established that the Laam seats are very good, but the best is the Russell due to those damn ugly wings. The incremental saddle comfort comes from your weight being supported over a wider area, including the back of your upper thighs by those wings.Before I totally sell out and go RDL - the Laam's look a bit better - are they as good for long distance?
@David Foley
Corbin seats work under the same principle as Russell, to spread your weight load they scoop the seat foam and attempt to relieve the hot spots that you get due to loss of circulation. The problem with a Corbin is it is not custom shaped, and not every butt is the same. There will be a small percentage of the population that can climb on one and be happy with the support because they will be lucky enough to have a corbin shaped butt Of course that is only until they climb onto a Russell, then it is pretty hard to make yourself go back to the Corbin "bricks"I have Corbin now - good for 600 miles/day but living in Texas you need a 1000 mile first day to get to the good roads.
@charleetho
That is a function of the stock seat on later gen bikes. The first gens the passenger seat is only slightly higher, maybe an inch, and the 2nd/3rd gen seats the passenger's is about 3" higher than the rider's, as you noticed. Russell does retain that height difference when they customize the passenger seat.What I noticed on the pics of passenger seats is they look 3" higher then the riders seat. My passenger would appreciate that if it's true. Our current Corbin is about level.
Last edited by a moderator: