I went through no less than 4 different shields on my bike ..before throwing on a laminar lip on the OEM shield and quickly settling on that. Wish I would have done it out of the gate and saved myself the PIA and drama and cost of various shields.
Perhaps not the most attractive, but it's been very durable for the last 65Kmiles. Personally I don't think they look that bad.
+1.
I tried Yami tall, VStream, and Cal-Sci before picking up an L/L for cheap from another forum member and putting it on the stock screen. Liked it better than any of the others, as it works well without being big as a barn door. I also can't imagine how anybody sitting behind a VStream can call a Laminar Lip fugly. They must walk backwards towards their bike before getting on. I'm 5'8" with 31" inseam, bike has Heli pullback risers and a Sargeant seat that sits slightly taller than stock. For the measly 50 bucks shipped I paid for that used Laminar lip, it's worth its weight in gold.