NC_Yank:
There's some interesting stuff in that long piece. Some stuff I've thought about and going to continue to think about. Truly.
Several jump out at me after an hour of contemplation and response drafting.
If a member does get disrespect toward another member then we let them know privately and we subsequently delete that particular post without calling them on the carpet in front of other members.
We don't censor around here. We do take people aside privately on matters that violate the guidelines (i.e. politics and religion) and don't make a big fuss about it publicly. We leave the post alone, and close threads occasionally when the overall conversation drifts into netherland.
We also don't censor when somebody starts taking personal shots at us--like JJ has we're not about to delete that thread. Our distates for censorship is a reason why this forum exists and a huge reason a bunch of folks bailed on
FJR Owners Assocation. You want to have your postings suppressed? Try going over to the other board and post a link to this forum my friend. Heir Newman will eat your lunch.
We don't suppress board operation opinions around here....just like we won't toast this thread.
But, just as we don't suppress other opinions we're going to speak up when we see something we disagree with.
Anyway, back to the rules........yes, they do bring order to things.....or at least they should.But they should also be applied to all equally.
I agree with this principal. I really am sincere when I say I don't know what circumstance you're talking about. Can you be more specific?
IMO, as a member here, you are treated as second class person......at least it comes off that way when you read the rules here. Clearly the way they are posted gives validity to your arroangancy comment.
Please don't confuse style with intent. As unorthodox as they may appear to you they have worked pretty well the past 15 months. They're blunt and direct and I hope you don't dwell on #7 too much. Using the tavern analogy it's intended for the metaphorical beligerent drunks as a last resort. To date, it's only happened to one person. Try searching on Downn2/Downn2(old) if you want to get a sense of how much of an asshole that guy was.
A forum in iteself means a place in which ideas and conversation is FREELY taken place.
It isn't free here? Hmm. I don't get that. I see lots of personal expression and I see lots of debate. I see some learning going on too.
#7. (This one gets me................I dont know how you treat your guest, but if you come to my house then I treat you with honor. You get the best chair, the best slice of steak, the last piece of pie.....and you get it without reservation. Such respect will foster even greater respect in return and even better....it will kindle a friendship........Lord knows we all need that in this day in time)
Yeah this one get's me too. We have a fundamental clash of opinion here.
It isn't like your house.
It's like a tavern.
One of the things that we mods have done in order to make our investment site better is simply have a section in which its members can freely make suggestions without having to worry about some heavy handed admin coming down on them.
....If not then you mind as well call this the FJR Blog where only a few can voice their opinions without feeling the retribution.
Seems a part of that has been covered here and ideas are being freely expressed. How to run the board isn't divisive like politics and religion are. Whether the board is 2500, 50, or more likely on the order of hundred of regularly posting and monitoring members we're going to consider changes that have broad appeal.
In closing, let me say to you admins......I do not know any of you personally,.......I have no personal animosity toward any of you.......I suspect that if I met many of you in person that we could honestly have an enjoyable dinner..............but really, as JJ said, some of you come off arrogant and condescending.
I'm sorry if you feel that way. I'm not intending it. I will always speak my mind and try and share my true intent. I'm here to talk about FJRs.
I do hope that the powers that be on this site take a step back and truly re-evaluate what their goal for this site is and if they are getting there in a manner which is beneficial to all. Obviously warchild consciously or subconsciously made reference to this in his addressing other admins.
This is the one that actually made me chuckle a little. Warchild wrote the core guidelines many months ago distilling what was, at that time, the path forward of a forum that was increasingly innundated with devisive religion and politics at the expense of FJR conversation. Too much noise drowning out the signal.
Finally, the goal of this site remains vividly clear and continue making the community grow as the premiere FJR forum. From
the Forum Guidelines often quoted here:
This forum is to discuss the Yamaha FJR1300 and the issues surrounding the FJR1300 community.