Why Cell Phones And Cars Don't Mix

Yamaha FJR Motorcycle Forum

Help Support Yamaha FJR Motorcycle Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.

RonC

Well-known member
Joined
Jun 13, 2005
Messages
197
Reaction score
1
I thought this was an interesting piece of research concerning cellphones and cars - and why we have to be considered 'survivors' every time we go out to ride.

Related Articles

· Hands-free kits do not reduce crash risk

16 July 2005

Web Links

· Transportation Research Part F: Traffic Psychology and Behaviour

· National Institute of Advanced Industrial Science and Technology

TALKING on a cellphone is more distracting for a driver than talking to a fellow passenger. And now we may know why.

While a car is moving, the strength of signal received by a driver's phone continually changes, and the phone often has to switch from one base station to another during a call. That causes a slight loss of sound quality, forcing the driver's brain to work harder to work out what the person at the other end is saying, say Takashi Hamada and colleagues at the National Institute of Advanced Industrial Science and Technology.

Hamada's team measured the sound quality of mobile phone calls in parked cars and in cars travelling at 65 kilometres per hour. A comparison of the two types of voice signal revealed silent periods of about 300 milliseconds interrupting the signal roughly six times a minute. They also discovered a time lag of about 300 milliseconds for a phone in a moving car, while for 5 per cent of the time, the frequency range becomes distorted.

The researchers then played 11 volunteers an audio recording of a story that included similar interruptions. As the volunteers struggled to hear the distorted parts of the recording, their right parietal cortex, the part of the brain that perceives sound, became more active (Transport Research Part F, DOI: 10.1016/j.trf.2005.04.016).

Previously, it was assumed that speaking to passengers was less distracting because they stop talking when the driver needs to concentrate.

Ron

 
Last edited by a moderator:
Previously, it was assumed that speaking to passengers was less distracting because they stop talking when the driver needs to concentrate.
[SIZE=14pt]They have obviously never driven with a woman in the car.........[/SIZE]

 
I have said for a long time that it is not the cell phone that is the major problem, it is the driver reacting to the information that his is getting from the phone. Good news, bad news, each tidbit causes the driver to do something other than control the car. He/she speeds up, slows down, reaches for a pen & paper to copy something, drifts out of lane....the list goes on and on. Build a cell phone that won't allow conversation unless the engine is off (really loud electrical noise?) and you may solve the problem. The hands free ear piece phone is not the solution.

 
Lets not forget the nice BIG SUV's with NavstarNavsatRunDVDMp3ondaDMZwitPCP and there gonna see my wittle blue *** !!! Trials bikes ...yeah dats the ticket...we'll ride OVER those suckas....all I want fer Christmas is a Sherco !!!!!

:D

Bobby

 
So, after starting this thread, what do we see? A young lady(?) pulls up beside us at a traffic light with a cell phone held to her ear with the left hand and a hamburger in the right. When the light turns green, she starts to drive off with NO HANDS! Maybe she was steering with her knees?

Arrrggghhhh!

Ron

 
I travel by car for business almost every day, so for me having a phone in the car is a necessity of sorts. In some cases, it's a good thing. Long interstate drives get so boring, and if you happen to be tired after a long day, drowsiness sets in. If this happens to me I will sometimes make a call just to wake myself up, since talking to someone else relieves the boredom. It beats falling asleep and having the rumble strips wake you up.

Of course the phone has a dark side - it can be a distraction, and learning to use the phone AND pay attention to your driving takes practice and self discipline. You need to learn to put driving first, and pull over if the signal is bad or the conversation too engaging. Not always easy to do, and most people don't bother to try, it seems. Hands free helps a little out on the open road, but is less effective when driving in a city where traffic density is greater.

Personally, I dream of the day when the damn car has autopilot and drives itself. Then I could actually get some work done during all that windshield time, or take a nap if I'm tired. Of course, a chauffer would work too, but I'm not that wealthy. :cownoy:

 
@windjammer: If you can drive while talking on the cell phone - you're one of the few that can do it well.

I see everyday evidence of cell phone abuse. It is the new legalised drunk driving.

 
@windjammer: If you can drive while talking on the cell phone - you're one of the few that can do it well.
Ya gotta pick your battles. If I'm in the city I leave the phone sit or I pull into a parking lot to talk. Out on the open two lane or freeway with minimal traffic, it's much easier to add the phone to your multi-tasking without overloading yourself to the point of distraction. And like anything else, lots of practice helps. You learn how not to use the phone in your car as you gain experience. A little like learning to ride a MC - after awhile, you learn where not to put yourself in traffic situations.

I see everyday evidence of cell phone abuse.
Me too. I don't like it any better than you do. Way too many people putting the phone yakking first, and driving a distant second, maybe even third or fourth.

It is the new legalised drunk driving.
That might be stretching it a little bit. But then I come from the perspective of being a guy who, as a younger man, routinely operated my MC while intoxicated, sometimes ridiculously so. I'm pretty sure I put myself in more danger then than I do now.
 
So, after starting this thread, what do we see? A young lady(?) pulls up beside us at a traffic light with a cell phone held to her ear with the left hand and a hamburger in the right. When the light turns green, she starts to drive off with NO HANDS! Maybe she was steering with her knees?Arrrggghhhh!

Ron


Those weren't her knees :lol: :lol: :lol: :lol: :lol:

 
Sunday morning on my way to work in good weather conditions, I come around a gentle curve just in time to see a Jeep SUV slide off the road and roll over down an embankment. As I was stopping and running down the embankment I was thinking ......, this has something to do with a cell phone. The Jeep was on it's side. The rear widow was blown out so I crawled in to help the girl out the back. She was not hurt but pretty hysterical. I asked what happened and she said her cell phone was ringing and she was trying to get it out of her purse.

I KNEW IT! :angry:

 
I think this is a record for resurrecting old threads... 3+ years. :blink:

Heeheee....

that does proved people can not multitask effectively.

Next time you're on the phone, pay attention to where you're attention is.... pbly about 6-10 FEET in front of you.

On the phone, people concentrate on the phone, NOT what else they're doing.

Driving (or riding) by itself is multitasking, add a phone to that and it's overwhelming.

Yeah, I do talk on the phone occasionally.... but unless it's on a long boring superslab somewhere, it's like, I'm driving, call me back later.

Mostly I just turn off the ringer, and check the calls later.

Ya'll take care and ride safe.

Mary

 
So I have never really understood why people can carry on a conversation with a passenger (or 2-3 if you have kids) but can't handle a conversation on a telephone, hands free or otherwise.

What about that makes it that much more distracting?

I mean I see it all the time, but I don't understand it.

 
So I have never really understood why people can carry on a conversation with a passenger (or 2-3 if you have kids) but can't handle a conversation on a telephone, hands free or otherwise.
What about that makes it that much more distracting?

I mean I see it all the time, but I don't understand it.
post #1 explained exactly why.

 
So I have never really understood why people can carry on a conversation with a passenger (or 2-3 if you have kids) but can't handle a conversation on a telephone, hands free or otherwise.
What about that makes it that much more distracting?

I mean I see it all the time, but I don't understand it.
post #1 explained exactly why.
And so it does...

 
I think this is a record for resurrecting old threads... 3+ years. :blink:
Sorry My fault. I was bored and wanted to see what would happen if I posted on a really old but interesting thread. Looks like it has gotten at least as many add on post as it did 3 years ago.

 
Top