Worth A Read

Yamaha FJR Motorcycle Forum

Help Support Yamaha FJR Motorcycle Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.
Here's an easier to read version of "the premise" of Shop Class as Soulcraft by Matt Crawfordhttps://www.nytimes.com/2009/05/24/magazine/24labor-t.html
Yea..., pictures -- now that's a good/fun read...! :)

Not only is Crawford's premise misguided (we're not going to re-do the industrial revolution...) -- only the folks who've already succeeded in society with degrees of higher learning (and the salaries they garner) find the need to idealize 'money-grubbing by manual labor'.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
I also think he's wrong in his premise that working with your hands (and getting paid poorly for it...) is a good thing.

He might as well try to bring back the family farm, too...
Maybe I missed it, but I thought the premise for his book is that our society wrongly de-values working with your hands and he builds a case for the virtues of working with your hands.
Another of his points is at the end of the day with a "working with your hands" job, you have a running motorcycle (or building wired for electricity, or whatever) whereas in a cube, you usually don't have a damn thing to show for a day's work besides the paycheck (and usually you can't even explain what you did to most mortals)

"Hey honey, I built an Oracle call center web service today!" - "That's nice, dear..."

 
The premise of the book is accurate even if you don't like the "Ph. D." way the message was delivered!
Yeah, which is why I'm sad it's so badly written. I wish it was a book I could give to friends and say "read this, it'll explain why I love rebuilding engines after a week of bashing on computers" but I can't...

 
"Hey honey, I built an Oracle call center web service today!" - "That's nice, dear..."
Man, isn't that the truth. "I wrote and configured a Cisco CRA server and script to intelligently handle calls coming in across 3 call centers with redundant backups"

I'd go back to being a high end cabinet maker in a second if I could. Damn allergy will be the death of me though.

 
I read the article that Michael linked and George's as well and I thought they both were damn interesting. So I went to the public library website to put a hold on Crawford's book. I'd have been 28th in line!

So thanks to you both for putting these out there. I expect I'll just buy the book, rather than wait, and I expect to forward it to my college senior daughter when I'm done. I think the message is, despite the value of educating yourself, you don't need to be locked onto a course for life that makes you miserable, and he argues convincingly that the very constrained "knowledge based" careers can do that. My daughter is artistic and extremely creative and imaginative. I can see how a bureaucratic career in the corporate world or any level of government could be soul-crushing for her. So much of what I got out of those articles rang true for me in my own life--and thank God my state government career is finally over! It would be a very good thing for her to consider his viewpoint before she heads down a similar path.

I admire anyone who has had the courage to follow a dream and make a dramatic career switch in midstream--even if it involves an investment of significant time and money. And even if the resulting, more fulfilling career ends up being much less well-paid. Hardly "money grubbing." I'd say that's what Crawford did, and it worked for him. And good for him for it.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
Here's an easier to read version of "the premise" of Shop Class as Soulcraft by Matt Crawford
https://www.nytimes.com/2009/05/24/magazine/24labor-t.html
Like OM, I hate to be one of those "Knobs" that recommends reading stuff, but I was just reading the section in the above article entitled "reader's comments". There were 140+ of them.

Here's the URL for the reader's comments; https://community.nytimes.com/comments/www..../24labor-t.html

Oh, and my disclaimer = I have received No compensation whatsoever and am un-affliliated with the author, the publisher, or the magazine, for the above recommendations.

I merely enjoyed my reading of them.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
Top