Deer Whistles...Are they any good?

Yamaha FJR Motorcycle Forum

Help Support Yamaha FJR Motorcycle Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.

NTXFJR

Well-known member
Joined
Oct 15, 2015
Messages
545
Reaction score
193
Location
Midlothian, Tx
I've been reading the posts about the unfortunate up close and in your face incidents with forest rats. I was at the dealer yesterday bs'ing with the parts manager and the forest rat subject came up. He recommended using a deer whistle. Has anyone had any experience with these?

 
Tried the non-electric type for a bit, did not do much for the deer on the road shoulders, got a couple of funny looks and they continued on with what they were doing.

 
Nope, they actually will cause them to move and from a friend's experience, they kept running out in front him. He lives next to a lake and have a bunch of deer down there. You don' want to startle them.

 
They may work for the deer just loitering near the road but they won't do squat for the one on already on the run crossing in front of you.

Back in the 80's when they deer whistles real popular I asked a guy at a body shop about them. His reply was "I fix as many cars with them and those without.

Spend your money on the best riding gear you can afford and hope you won't need it.

 
If there was any evidence that they worked at all automobile insurance companies would either require them or give a discount for using them...ff

 
Good points on the deer whistles.

I can say this from experience: around 6 weeks ago I had a doe trot out of the woods and up to the shoulder of the road in Huntsville Tx and she thankfully paused there for a bit while staring at me. I was doing 65 mph and would not have been able to stop in time, but I did have time to get on the Stebel horn I had installed not long before that and she turned tail bagging ass back into the trees. No telling what she would've done otherwise, I'd like to think that horn saved my bacon that day.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
Never tried them.

I heard if you install them backwards they call the deer to you...
whistle.gif
whistle.gif


 
Last edited by a moderator:
My dad's hit a deer with his Goldwing. He put deer passive deer whistles on after that, then proceeded to hit 2 more.

Maybe he just installed them backwards so now they attract instead of repel?
fool.gif


 
Whistles and horns.... they may cause a critter to move, but in which direction is unpredictable. The deer that hit me in August was at full run when it cleared the brush, the only thing that was going to stop it was me. Montana has the distinction of ranking No. 2 in the nation for auto versus deer, elk or moose collisions (two local riders died this year after hitting elk), according to a report by State Farm insurance company based on the number of claims filed. The study places the odds at 1:58 in Montana. West Virginia is first at 1:41 and Pennsylvania is third at 1:67. I think the only way to mitigate the risk is to avoid riding from dusk to dawn and to slow down in areas where there is a higher risk of wildlife crossing an/or getting close to the road without being seen. But you need to accept that hitting or getting hit by an animal is sometimes unavoidable.

 
After I hit my third forest rat in 2010 (and lost a nice Wing), out of desperation I tried a Hornet https://www.xp3hornet.com/ "amplified" unit on my GSX1100G. A complete waste of money. 22 ga. wire, when I saw that, I didn't have hope that it would be overly loud - and it's not. Tried it out on Skyline Dr., known for its infestation of forest rats. A doe grazing at the side of the road glanced up at me as I rode by and went back to eating. Best way to avoid deer, in my experience - if you're lucky enough to see them in time - is to mount the loudest horn you can find and hold the button down as you approach them. They don't like loud sounds and, if they perceive the sound as approaching them, will usually go the other way. Also, if one darts across the road in front of me, I hold the button down till I'm well past that spot. I've seen the ones following the leader hesitate at the side of the road, then dart across when I'm almost there; this gives the "hesitators" some incentive to go back the way they came, YMMV.

 
Top