Do I have a brake problem?

Yamaha FJR Motorcycle Forum

Help Support Yamaha FJR Motorcycle Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.
Try to lock the front on gravel- abs should pulse the brake and prevent lockup....does the abs light come on ?

Yeah - that sounds like a good way to find out the ABS is no good - intentional front end lock in gravel. The good news is that its an efficient way to check your ABS AND your frame sliders in one brief test.
So apparently none of you hosers ever rode dirt

If the dm thing locks..let off ..geez
On a dirt bike yes. On a 640 lb street bike? Nah.
back in my squid days we used to mark some lines on the pavement and see who could stop from 60 in the shortest distance...amazing how it is possible to modulate the front brake to and thru the point of lockup- the wheel will lock as weight transfers back as the bike slows..

once I was following a guy on a Harley and watched as he locked the rear and laid down about 60 feet of rubber as he tried to stop behind a left turning car and slammed into it-sadly the guy died on the pavement in front of my eyes.He never touched the front brake

abs was invented for those who won't learn to use the front brake to the max.. your life should be in your right hand...not your ****..

 
"Your life should be in your right hand...not your ****..."

My new favorite quote!!

If some of you cannot confidently bring your front wheel to lock up and release it, you need to goto some classes. Learning to use the brakes to their potential can be unnerving, but you'd be surprised what they will do.

Even on a 600lb+ beast..

 
Last edited by a moderator:
Those front wheel lockup classes must be a hoot to watch as people explore the envelope of their newly learned skill. Do they post the early sessions on YouTube?
tonguesmiley.gif


I can't believe that we've gone this far into an ABS thread without anyone suggesting installing the ABS test jumper and running the diag to exercise the pump. It is an effective way to move some fluid through the pump and spools (valves) of the hydraulic block, and check that the ABS will (most likely) work when you need it. Yeah, by all means go practice engaging the ABS once you are fairly confident it is actually gonna work for you.

BTW - You do not always get an ABS light when there are problems with the system. Several people with frozen spools have proven that to be true.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
...I can't believe that we've gone this far into an ABS thread without anyone suggesting installing the ABS test jumper and running the diag to exercise the pump. It is an effective way to move some fluid through the pump and spools (valves) of the hydraulic block, and check that the ABS will (most likely) work when you need it...
I believe I have referenced it at least twice and supplied a link. And, here is it yet again to reinforce your mention and link

Safely test your ABS system without having to take the risk of locking up your front or rear wheels and move fresh brake fluid into the metering block spool valves.

 
I have more questions for the techies since I have questioned whether my rear ABS is working......... I have gone too hot approaching a curve and have applied rear brake to scrub off a bit of speed (with perhaps no or a little front braking) on dry pavement or damp, and the rear wheel locks up with no pulsing felt. Rear tire can slide for a fair distance....... might have something to do with perhaps a weight shift forward, as it has happened on downhill slopes (and also wondering if the big fat car tire might contribute due to the large surface area, but that's a whole other discussion). In these cases, speed was I'm guessing 30-50 mph, which should be well above where the ABS should kick in.

I have not run the jumper diagnostic test yet, however this past weekend I purposely tested the rear ABS while on damp pavement. At 35 mph, rear brake only, I could get two significant pulses in the pedal (audible click as well) until I slowed what I think would be below the ABS cutoff speed. Three tests, same thing. Pulses/clicks were quite distinct and I'm guessing a frequency of 2-3 per second. I was expecting perhaps double or triple that. Tested the front in a similar manner and pulses were indeed a much higher frequency that I expected. So my conclusion is the ABS is working sorta, but how should it work........ no official technical info seems to exist. Could it be if my test speed were higher, would the rear pulse much more rapidly?

Elsewhere in this thread, the metering valve has been mentioned. This is a separate component from the ABS pump assembly and a new one costs ~$175. Does anyone know what this thing does? It does not appear to have any electrical connections, just mechano-hydraulic internals...... is this the one that gets "stuck"? Has anybody replaced one and that fixed your issue? I want your old one for surgery........... There is also a proportioning valve, but that typically just balances the amount of braking front to rear. So, do I replace the metering valve?

For those who have physically tested or encountered the rear ABS to kick in (rear brake applied only or mostly), how fast do the pulses come, fast buzz or slow and deliberate? How about fatsiders with a larger diameter rear tire?

I am not going to be able to complete my diagnosis before next spring (many reasons), but future testing will include the jumper test, plus a physical test with an OEM size 180 rear tire, then perhaps a fatside tire. I have done regular flush and bleeds. I also question whether fluid is really being moved during the jumper test..... it's a closed system, where's it going to go?

Anyway, seeking the collective wisdom here, hoping we'll all learn more. BTW, I did score a spare low mileage ABS pump on ebay, which I was originally thinking I would swap out. That was before my road test.... but, maybe I'll go to all that work at some point next year.

 
I have more questions for the techies since I have questioned whether my rear ABS is working......... I have gone too hot approaching a curve and have applied rear brake to scrub off a bit of speed (with perhaps no or a little front braking) on dry pavement or damp, and the rear wheel locks up with no pulsing felt. Rear tire can slide for a fair distance....... might have something to do with perhaps a weight shift forward, as it has happened on downhill slopes (and also wondering if the big fat car tire might contribute due to the large surface area, but that's a whole other discussion). In these cases, speed was I'm guessing 30-50 mph, which should be well above where the ABS should kick in. ABS low speed shut-off happens between 7-8 mph, at that point there is too little inertia in the chassis. There are a lot of dynamics taking place in your description. Was the slide linear (upright and straight forward) or radial (leaned over in a turn)? The FJR ABS is effective only in linear wheel speed control.

I have not run the jumper diagnostic test yet, however this past weekend I purposely tested the rear ABS while on damp pavement. At 35 mph, rear brake only, I could get two significant pulses in the pedal (audible click as well) until I slowed what I think would be below the ABS cutoff speed. Three tests, same thing. Pulses/clicks were quite distinct and I'm guessing a frequency of 2-3 per second. I was expecting perhaps double or triple that. Tested the front in a similar manner and pulses were indeed a much higher frequency that I expected. So my conclusion is the ABS is working sorta, but how should it work........ no official technical info seems to exist. Could it be if my test speed were higher, would the rear pulse much more rapidly? The ABS ECU monitors many things but the prime inputs are wheel speed and vehicle chassis speed. When wheel speed and chassis speed are equal the ratio is 1:1 and slip angle is 100%. As wheel speed and chassis speed start to become divergent, wheel lockup becomes imminent. When the wheel speed to chassis speed is not equal the chassis remains 1 but the wheel becomes :0.90 1:.90 and slip angle is 90%. The critical point arrives at a slip angle of 87%, this is considered to be the transition to skid -- at 89% the wheel is turning and not skidding, at 85% the wheel is effectively skidding and on the way to locking up. The ABS ECU will start to modulate the hydraulic pressure to keep the slip angle higher than 87%. There is no one set reaction from the ABS unit, it will vary with the ratio of chassis to wheel speed.

Elsewhere in this thread, the metering valve has been mentioned. This is a separate component from the ABS pump assembly and a new one costs ~$175. Does anyone know what this thing does? It does not appear to have any electrical connections, just mechano-hydraulic internals...... is this the one that gets "stuck"? Has anybody replaced one and that fixed your issue? I want your old one for surgery........... There is also a proportioning valve, but that typically just balances the amount of braking front to rear. So, do I replace the metering valve? I don't have a FSM with me today so the 'metering valve' is a bit of a mystery. I do know about the proportioning valve in the linked braking system and you are correct about that. At least on the Gen I there is no external metering valve and all stuck solenoids have been internal to the metering block. Because the Gen I brakes are not linked a proportioning valve is not needed.

For those who have physically tested or encountered the rear ABS to kick in (rear brake applied only or mostly), how fast do the pulses come, fast buzz or slow and deliberate? How about fatsiders with a larger diameter rear tire? During the ABS jumper test the pulse rate is described in the FSM. If you are talking about on the road, it will vary depending on how hard the ABS ECU needs to work to keep the slip angle under control. In terms of tire size, by the book, the coefficient of friction is independent of surface area but real world dynamics can cause contact surface area and force to vary during braking. Grab a handful of front brake and the weight load on the rear tire can drop to 15% of vehicle weight as the weight transfers to the front wheel. Weight transfer will cause different reactions from the ABS ECU depending if the braking is biased primarily on the rear brake or biased primarily on the front brake.

I am not going to be able to complete my diagnosis before next spring (many reasons), but future testing will include the jumper test, plus a physical test with an OEM size 180 rear tire, then perhaps a fatside tire. I have done regular flush and bleeds. I also question whether fluid is really being moved during the jumper test..... it's a closed system, where's it going to go? Brake fluid is recirculated as the ABS pump runs and the accumulator and spool valves are cycled. Over a series of cycles the accumulator and spools will be flushed of old fluid, and whatever was in these cavities will now be in the brake lines.

Anyway, seeking the collective wisdom here, hoping we'll all learn more. BTW, I did score a spare low mileage ABS pump on ebay, which I was originally thinking I would swap out. That was before my road test.... but, maybe I'll go to all that work at some point next year. The unknown on the bench vs the known in your FJR -- you've gotta ask yourself a question: "Do I feel lucky?" Well, do ya, punk?"
wink.png
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Try to lock the front on gravel- abs should pulse the brake and prevent lockup....does the abs light come on ?

Yeah - that sounds like a good way to find out the ABS is no good - intentional front end lock in gravel. The good news is that its an efficient way to check your ABS AND your frame sliders in one brief test.
So apparently none of you hosers ever rode dirt

If the dm thing locks..let off ..geez
Well, yeah. I used to practice seeing how far I could push my front wheel on my motocross bike. But I'd have to respectfully agree that I wouldn't recommend someone lock the front wheel on gravel intentionally.

 
I have more questions for the techies since I have questioned whether my rear ABS is working......... I have gone too hot approaching a curve and have applied rear brake to scrub off a bit of speed (with perhaps no or a little front braking) on dry pavement or damp, and the rear wheel locks up with no pulsing felt. Rear tire can slide for a fair distance....... might have something to do with perhaps a weight shift forward, as it has happened on downhill slopes (and also wondering if the big fat car tire might contribute due to the large surface area, but that's a whole other discussion). In these cases, speed was I'm guessing 30-50 mph, which should be well above where the ABS should kick in.
How about downshifting? If your right at the point of the ABS kicking in, would an abrupt downshift coupled with an abrupt clutch release lock the rear wheel momentarily? I've had my brakes -- both of 'em -- chatter pretty good on a fun crooked road. Never locked one up, but I've wondered if a sudden downshift would do so.

 
I have more questions for the techies since I have questioned whether my rear ABS is working......... I have gone too hot approaching a curve and have applied rear brake to scrub off a bit of speed (with perhaps no or a little front braking) on dry pavement or damp, and the rear wheel locks up with no pulsing felt. Rear tire can slide for a fair distance....... might have something to do with perhaps a weight shift forward, as it has happened on downhill slopes (and also wondering if the big fat car tire might contribute due to the large surface area, but that's a whole other discussion). In these cases, speed was I'm guessing 30-50 mph, which should be well above where the ABS should kick in.
How about downshifting? If you're right at the point of the ABS kicking in, would an abrupt downshift coupled with an abrupt clutch release lock the rear wheel momentarily? I've had my brakes -- both of 'em -- chatter pretty good on a fun crooked road. Never locked one up, but I've wondered if a sudden downshift would do so.
 
I have more questions for the techies since I have questioned whether my rear ABS is working......... I have gone too hot approaching a curve and have applied rear brake to scrub off a bit of speed (with perhaps no or a little front braking) on dry pavement or damp, and the rear wheel locks up with no pulsing felt. Rear tire can slide for a fair distance....... might have something to do with perhaps a weight shift forward, as it has happened on downhill slopes (and also wondering if the big fat car tire might contribute due to the large surface area, but that's a whole other discussion). In these cases, speed was I'm guessing 30-50 mph, which should be well above where the ABS should kick in.
How about downshifting? If you're right at the point of the ABS kicking in, would an abrupt downshift coupled with an abrupt clutch release lock the rear wheel momentarily? I've had my brakes -- both of 'em -- chatter pretty good on a fun crooked road. Never locked one up, but I've wondered if a sudden downshift would do so.
Simple answer is the ABS will do what it can.

If you drop the clutch in so that the rear wheel would skip with no brake applied, then that would still happen while braking. If the wheel wouldn't skip with no braking, then if you are braking, the ABS will release the brake as required.

 
Simple answer is the ABS will do what it can.

If you drop the clutch in so that the rear wheel would skip with no brake applied, then that would still happen while braking. If the wheel wouldn't skip with no braking, then if you are braking, the ABS will release the brake as required.
That's sort of what I was thinking. If the cause of the lockup were hard braking and a downshift the brake would compensate -- I think. But the opening post had me scratching my head and going "Hmmm...."

 
Simple answer is the ABS will do what it can.

If you drop the clutch in so that the rear wheel would skip with no brake applied, then that would still happen while braking. If the wheel wouldn't skip with no braking, then if you are braking, the ABS will release the brake as required.
That's sort of what I was thinking. If the cause of the lockup were hard braking and a downshift the brake would compensate -- I think. But the opening post had me scratching my head and going "Hmmm...."
Of course, if you had the 'AS', it wouldn't drop the clutch out that quickly anyway :) .

 
Simple answer is the ABS will do what it can.

If you drop the clutch in so that the rear wheel would skip with no brake applied, then that would still happen while braking. If the wheel wouldn't skip with no braking, then if you are braking, the ABS will release the brake as required.
That's sort of what I was thinking. If the cause of the lockup were hard braking and a downshift the brake would compensate -- I think. But the opening post had me scratching my head and going "Hmmm...."
Of course, if you had the 'AS', it wouldn't drop the clutch out that quickly anyway
smile.png
.
I understand. A two-stroke would be useful as well. ;)

 
I have more questions for the techies since I have questioned whether my rear ABS is working......... I have gone too hot approaching a curve and have applied rear brake to scrub off a bit of speed (with perhaps no or a little front braking) on dry pavement or damp, and the rear wheel locks up with no pulsing felt. Rear tire can slide for a fair distance....... might have something to do with perhaps a weight shift forward, as it has happened on downhill slopes (and also wondering if the big fat car tire might contribute due to the large surface area, but that's a whole other discussion). In these cases, speed was I'm guessing 30-50 mph, which should be well above where the ABS should kick in.
How about downshifting? If your right at the point of the ABS kicking in, would an abrupt downshift coupled with an abrupt clutch release lock the rear wheel momentarily? I've had my brakes -- both of 'em -- chatter pretty good on a fun crooked road. Never locked one up, but I've wondered if a sudden downshift would do so.
If you downshift from a speed that will cause your rear to lock up, it will lock up until you slow enough for the wheel to catch up, or you dump the bike. Usually only a second or two, but the ABS has nothing to do with what the clutch causes the rear wheel to do. Unless you are riding one of those weird one lever bikes.
no.gif


 
I have more questions for the techies since I have questioned whether my rear ABS is working......... I have gone too hot approaching a curve and have applied rear brake to scrub off a bit of speed (with perhaps no or a little front braking) on dry pavement or damp, and the rear wheel locks up with no pulsing felt. Rear tire can slide for a fair distance....... might have something to do with perhaps a weight shift forward, as it has happened on downhill slopes (and also wondering if the big fat car tire might contribute due to the large surface area, but that's a whole other discussion). In these cases, speed was I'm guessing 30-50 mph, which should be well above where the ABS should kick in.
How about downshifting? If your right at the point of the ABS kicking in, would an abrupt downshift coupled with an abrupt clutch release lock the rear wheel momentarily? I've had my brakes -- both of 'em -- chatter pretty good on a fun crooked road. Never locked one up, but I've wondered if a sudden downshift would do so.
If you downshift from a speed that will cause your rear to lock up, it will lock up until you slow enough for the wheel to catch up, or you dump the bike. Usually only a second or two, but the ABS has nothing to do with what the clutch causes the rear wheel to do. Unless you are riding one of those weird one lever bikes.
no.gif
I understand that. Under heavy braking, at least on my lighter bike, the rear gets so light that I can easily get it sliding with a rough downshift. I was just trying to work through my head if a person did that while braking just short of lock up, the ABS would be quick enough to compensate or if it might slide a bit. Obviously, if it's a clutch-induced slide only the ABS would have no effect.

 
I have more questions for the techies since I have questioned whether my rear ABS is working......... I have gone too hot approaching a curve and have applied rear brake to scrub off a bit of speed (with perhaps no or a little front braking) on dry pavement or damp, and the rear wheel locks up with no pulsing felt. Rear tire can slide for a fair distance....... might have something to do with perhaps a weight shift forward, as it has happened on downhill slopes (and also wondering if the big fat car tire might contribute due to the large surface area, but that's a whole other discussion). In these cases, speed was I'm guessing 30-50 mph, which should be well above where the ABS should kick in.
How about downshifting? If your right at the point of the ABS kicking in, would an abrupt downshift coupled with an abrupt clutch release lock the rear wheel momentarily? I've had my brakes -- both of 'em -- chatter pretty good on a fun crooked road. Never locked one up, but I've wondered if a sudden downshift would do so.
If you downshift from a speed that will cause your rear to lock up, it will lock up until you slow enough for the wheel to catch up, or you dump the bike. Usually only a second or two, but the ABS has nothing to do with what the clutch causes the rear wheel to do. Unless you are riding one of those weird one lever bikes.
no.gif
I understand that. Under heavy braking, at least on my lighter bike, the rear gets so light that I can easily get it sliding with a rough downshift. I was just trying to work through my head if a person did that while braking just short of lock up, the ABS would be quick enough to compensate or if it might slide a bit. Obviously, if it's a clutch-induced slide only the ABS would have no effect.
I think I have made my rear slide doing exactly that...Downshift and a hair too much brake coming into a curve too hot. I know the rear slid for at least some time, because I was concerned there was an ABS issue. I tested it later and it was fine. I think it was a combination of the two forces working together and the ABS computer trying to catch up.

 
Nope, you guys are a little off track.... the situations have been three or four...... kinda like this.... either 3rd gear high revs or 4th gear slightly less revs, at least 60 mph and slowed to about 50 mph, and no downshifts were performed. It happened when I thought I could just use rear brake to scrub off some speed BEFORE the curve, put on some more rear as I realized the curve was going to decrease radius more quickly than expected and did not grab any or very little front (yup, I've flamed myself each time for poor technique there for sure). Rear wheel slid locked up for at least 50 feet, while grabbing front brakes brought it all under control. Another time, popped over a hill and had to hit brakes hard while on the downhill, no downshifting, but had grabbed both front and rear brakes. Rear wheel slid until I backed off on the rears. In all cases, I was expecting the rear ABS to prevent lockup or go into a pulsating lockup/unlock. Didn't happen.

I have had one occasion where in a panic stop, both brakes where weight transfer to the front was quite significant, and with so little weight on the rear wheel it also wanted to skid......... totally understand this is beyond the limits of the ABS to avoid a skid at that point, and have no problem with that scenario.

Edit/add - I think I'm beginning to understand why some have posted their rear ABS may not be working, when it MIGHT be that it's simply a matter of the system does not react to what we typically would think it should, i.e., does not release a lockup under certain conditions... I'll only say if that's true, I'm disappointed in the design. As well, I would never recommend "testing" on gravel or sand, you cannot predict if/how you're going to slide sideways on the "marbles" and go down. Better to do this on straight, good but damp asphalt where conditions will be more constant if that makes sense..

Alan, thanks for the detailed explanation, it is very helpful to my understanding (although I'm re-reading to grasp it all). Maybe my updated description of the "events" might help......

I had opportunity today to look under the side cover while doing a clutch soak on a buddy's 2010..... the metering valve is a separate block, with a "line out" from the ABS pump into it, and a "line in" from the metering valve back to the pump. Actually, I took pictures...... I'll review and recheck the plumbing arrangement for the proportioning valve....... the frame hides some of the lines.... will post up later.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
First photo shows ABS pump unit with 3 steel lines on top and two pointing towards us (round thing is the pump motor). The top left line is what I'll call "line out" to the metering valve (lower right corner, you can only see the rearmost end of it). The top middle line appears to be a "return" from the metering valve back to the ABS pump unit. The top right one and the two pointing right at us go into junction blocks.... the rubber brake line I believe goes to the rear caliper........... the proportioning valve block is hiding as it resides behind those blocks and slightly forward. Metering valve is below these junction blocks and sitting over the rectangular rear subframe.

See picture 2

P1020445_zps5ed0549f.jpg


In picture 2 we see the metering valve at the bottom over the rectangular subframe, directly above are junction blocks.... the two pointing forward go to the front brakes IIRC. Behind them and down, actually inboard of the metering valve, is the proportioning valve closer to the air box..........

In actuality, all this was done in haste as we were concentrating on a clutch soak, not ABS...... I will pull the cover off my bike and provide a better identification at some point in the future. The idea at this point is simply to show that Gen II has a metering valve for the ABS and a proportioning valve (for the linked brakes). There are quite a number of specially bent steel brake lines concentrated under the front steering head..... one of them is the clutch line........ hard to trace them back without the tank and plastic off. One will go to each caliper for front braking, and the right caliper has another one for the linked rear brake.

P1020444_zps98de1e76.jpg


 
Top