I know of a few good surgeons that I work with here, but a bit out of your area. Typically, most good ophthamologists are very busy now. With the increasing baby boomers, the line is getting longer.
As you said, our typical m.o. is a cataract evalutation appt. then surgery scheduled. You will come back a day after the surgery, then a 1 week follow up and a final exam at 4 to 5 weeks after surgery. It takes that much time for the eye to heal completely and get a final refraction. Most today come out without any post operative correction, except readers, but there are exceptions.
Go with who your ophthamologist reccomended, he should know. Look for a Dr. who has been at it a while, but not the one who learned from Moses. There is fine mix between experience and education.
good luck