I have geico. Progressive wanted over 1700 a year for full coverage. 90 for liability only. I checked with Geico, which I am not a fan of (due to business practices) and insurance was 700/year.
Here's my details. In the last three years:
1 ticket for doing 96 in a 75 (I-80 about 30 miles from Wendover, NV).
1 accident, my fault. Rear ended another vehicle.
1 claim when my boat rear-ended my truck. Oops.
So all in all, I am happy with my price. My auto insurance company doesn't do sports cars or motorcycles. So, I had to do something outside of my carrier.
Check around. And then check some more.
Eventually you will find a good deal.
I am in Utah, 32, home owner.