bramfrank
BramFrank
With all respect;
A D2S HID puts out some 3200 lumens (on average) from 35 watts of high voltage power (on average). If you are measuring 60 watts your ballasts truly suck. Modern ballasts run 90+% efficiency.
Yes, HIDs do draw more on ignition, but once warmed up (usually within 20 seconds on most modern designs), the current drawn by a decent ballast will settle to below 40 watts for a 35 watt bulb.
So your 1800 lumen LED device consumes about 20 watts. Your 3200 Lumen HID device consumes about 40 watts.
Of course, for your 'extra' current you DO get almost twice as much light as your high power LED provides. And it is more useable light because it can be properly aimed, assuming that your bulb is in an appropriate fixture and the right bulb (S or R) is used in the application. LEDs are cute, but they tend to spray light forward through tiny lenses directly moulded into them.
I'm guessing that your telescoping bulbs were used in a conversion, which is, among other things not legal - but the reflector in the FJR is simply not designed to be used with the large plasma source of an HID, making such conversions less than perfect. Let's see what you get if you stuff a 3-LED-array in there (intended to use the OEM optics for focus) using today's technology; . . . I'd be willing to wager pink slips that it wouldn;t work well at all.
A D2S HID puts out some 3200 lumens (on average) from 35 watts of high voltage power (on average). If you are measuring 60 watts your ballasts truly suck. Modern ballasts run 90+% efficiency.
Yes, HIDs do draw more on ignition, but once warmed up (usually within 20 seconds on most modern designs), the current drawn by a decent ballast will settle to below 40 watts for a 35 watt bulb.
So your 1800 lumen LED device consumes about 20 watts. Your 3200 Lumen HID device consumes about 40 watts.
Of course, for your 'extra' current you DO get almost twice as much light as your high power LED provides. And it is more useable light because it can be properly aimed, assuming that your bulb is in an appropriate fixture and the right bulb (S or R) is used in the application. LEDs are cute, but they tend to spray light forward through tiny lenses directly moulded into them.
I'm guessing that your telescoping bulbs were used in a conversion, which is, among other things not legal - but the reflector in the FJR is simply not designed to be used with the large plasma source of an HID, making such conversions less than perfect. Let's see what you get if you stuff a 3-LED-array in there (intended to use the OEM optics for focus) using today's technology; . . . I'd be willing to wager pink slips that it wouldn;t work well at all.