Smokers (BBQ - not grilling)

Yamaha FJR Motorcycle Forum

Help Support Yamaha FJR Motorcycle Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.
I'll definitely be smokin' up some fatties and some ABTs soon, very soon. Might not be able to wait till I have the new smoker fully farkled, seasoned and dialed in and just have to do some up on the GKD
tonguesmiley.gif


Just thinkin' out loud here... I've always loved the broiled or pan cooked, bacon wrapped scallop Hors d'oeuvres. I'm betting that a nice smoking would make 'em even bettah!

 
Last edited by a moderator:
My brother-in-law just got back from a road trip to the mid-west and apparently got the barbeque bug. He bought a Big Green Egg somewhere in Missouri and strapped it into the back seat of his Saturn ION and hauled it around until he got home Tuesday nite. I don't know what size he got or what 'egg-sessories' he got with it, but I know he'll be adventurous with it. Looks like I'll be getting some good eats.
smile.png


 
Here's a quick shot of mine w/ Boston Butts going.

1231688_10200544876521264_781912924_n.jpg


It's a gas smoker as I like to set it and forget it. So you have the burner, smoke box, water tray and then food trays. I've had 60lbs of pork in it at one time. It's thin sheet metal but I have a thermal blanket I put on it for winter smoking and it works like a charm. $199 at bass pro shops for the smoker. I cater many a party using this bad boy.

one more w/ some ribs in it. :)

603681_4776443765873_789296934_n.jpg


wait, my thanksgiving Turkey...

391278_2266376095750_1151115110_n.jpg


 
Besides being a helluva smoker, the other thing I like about the Traeger is it's ability to grill a steak. Tonight's grub was three juicy ribeye steaks. Debbie and the boy barely spoke a word during dinner. A good sign that the steaks were perfect...

i-pkdLtfz-XL.jpg


 
@Octopi - Nice looking pit going there. The more I see of them the more likely I am to eventually go with a chest style smoker. They just seem so refined and easy.

@nankoweap (what does that name mean anyway?) It seems that some pits do have the ability to sear meat as well as smoking it (in different configurations), but I think any time you have that you give up something to get that kind of versatility. Either the smoker isn't optimum, the searing grille isn't the best, or you give up a huge amount of cash to get something that really is capable of both.

Rather than parting with that much coin, most folks just have multiple grilles, and I think that will always be the case for me around here even if I do end up going "whole hog" into smoking. I have plenty od space in the backyard to clutter up with multiple grilles. ;)

Did you use the reverse searing technique on those rib eyes? Sorta looks like you did as the outside isn't as dark as a normal sear.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
As far as I can tell, Fred, the only thing I'm giving up grilling with the Traeger are some nicely defined grill marks. :) And I understand what you're saying, for sure. I was skeptical of its grillability, but am pleased. Definitely no reverse searing. I just set the temp on 375, let it preheat and slap the steaks on. About 10 minutes per side depending on how one likes them cooked. We're medium-rare/medium in the Jonas household.

Ain't nothing wrong with a multi-smoker/grill household. Can't have just one bike. Why should we be expected to have one grill? :)

Nankoweap... let's use the way-back machine and go to 2002 when I posted this on the MTF...

as far as 'nankoweap' goes... nankoweap is a side canyon in the grand canyon river system. while river rafting the grand canyon one summer, we spent the afternoon hiking and roaming around nankoweap. while sitting on top of a ridge near the granaries and looking down nankoweap canyon and the mighty colorado river i experienced a moment. a moment when the cosmos speak to those who will listen. i will never forget that day or that brief moment i was able to hear the stuff of life. nankoweap, along with a few other spots in the canyon, is a power spot and a special place for me.
i use it here and in other places because when i day dream or have lucid dreams, i typically find myself flying through the canyon and look down on that spot at nankoweap.
 
Jesus!!! I've never smoked meat in my life. NOW, I'm thinking about getting in to it. I Hate you people! Carry On Please! :))
Give it a go. Cooking meat on a smoker can be extremely simple or very complicated. The best thing in the world is when you toss a piece of meat on the smoker, then go inside and sit and drink beer and watch sports for several hours. Then later you pull it off the smoker and serve it up. People go nuts and ask how you did it and you explain that it was x number of hours on the smoker and somehow they think you spent that many hours cooking and they gobble it up. All the while you sit and smile and think of the 10 total minutes you invested into this crowd pleasing meal.

biggrin.png


 
Damn! Sounds tempting. Might look into it. I'll start paying attention To all the links provided here. I'm more of an Anthony Bourdain type of guy than anything else. Learned and enjoyed eating everything he's done on his show. Not afraid of smoking though. :)

 
If you are bored and enjoy spending your alone time looking at porn....erm, food porn that is. You might give a gander over here. It's a long thread but you won't regret it.
biggrin.png
It's the Two Wheeled Texans Mega BBQ thread.

https://www.twtex.com/forums/showthread.php?t=49100

And if ya decide to join up, don't worry, you don't have to be a Texan to be a member. Oddly, it's one of the biggest Suzuki Bandit boards around. We have members from all over the world. It's a strange thing, but it works. Heck, we've even had members who moved away that still ride in from NM or Kansas for our pie runs.
biggrin.png


 
Funny, I was reading back over that thread a little and stumbled upon the link for the Minion method.

No...not this guy ->
photo.jpg


Anyway, the UDS uses the minion method for using charcoal, been doing it all along and never knew it. I don't use briquettes though but lump charcoal instead. Anyway, this explains why you don't have to spend all day stoking the charcoal. This doesn't work well on the inexpensive charcoal cookers though as they usually don't have a very large space to hold enough charcoal.

Minion Method

 
OK, well... I received my COS last Friday. It is a Char Broil American Gourmet 300 series offset smoker. It is pretty small in size, but I should be able to do some decent sized pieces of meat. The smoking chamber (larger cylinder) is 24'" long and about 12" wide, so whole chickens won't be a problem, but, probably no whole turkeys.

Put it together and started the seasoning process per the instructions. Just built a charcoal briquette fire in the firebox on the provided grate and tossed on a few pieces of wood for effect, and to get things properly "seasoned" in the smoking chamber.

smokerbeforemods.jpg



During the burn-in, I immediately noticed a few problems with this smoker in its stock form. The biggest downfall is that the temperature gradient in the smoking chamber is way too big. The left side nearest the firebox would be almost 300 degrees and the right side is only 200 or less. Also, maintaining any sort of steady heat would seem to be a problem as the temperature in the smoking chamber would rise very quickly to higher than desired.

Time to farkle!

(disclaimer: Yes, I am a tinkerer. I like to mess around and design or redesign things on the fly. I just get an idea and I try to cob something together using readily available materials)

First challenge was to get more fuel into the firebox for a steadier burn. Just throwing charcoal inside the sheet metal firebox might get the job done, but the air flow to the charcoal wouldn't be good, and the sheet metal box would erode quickly. So I got a 1' x 2' piece of expanded metal (cost ~ $10) and fabbed up a screen charcoal box to go inside. This will provide a mini-Minion method burn and should extend the time between fuel feedings somewhat.

100_4183.jpg



The box is 8"x8" and 6" high. To make this box from the one sheet of expanded metal take the 24" long sheet and cut 8" off one end, then cut the remaining 16" lengthwise into two 6" x 16" pieces. Bend the two 16" pieces into right angles and I used pieces of coat hanger to join the ends to form the box. You could just drop the formed box on top of the stock wire grate, but I opted to bend up the ends of that extra 8" piece, place that on top of the grate and just drop the box on top of that before filling it. Still have plenty of access for adding fuel through the door.


Next, I decided that, in order to make the smoking chamber temperature more uniform, I would want to convert the smoker into a reverse flow smoker. Here's the idea...

Normally the smoke and heat from the firebox enter the smoking chamber from the lower left side and just waft across the smoking chamber on the way over to the chimney / exhaust on the right. So the left side of the smoking chamber is too hot and the right side is too cool. To make a reverse flow you just need to relocate the chimney to the firebox side of the smoking chamber and then build a baffle to make the smoke travel all the way across the bottom of the chamber before allowing it to rise up to the meat on the grilles in the upper half of the chamber.

Here's a diagram of a reverse flow smoker (this would be looking at my smoker from behind)

ReverseFlowDiagram.jpg


A 2' long x 9 1/4" piece of sheet metal forms the baffle plate, bent at the end and fastened to the end of the chamber using the screws that join the two chambers, blocks off the upper part of the hole between the firebox and smoke chamber.

100_4184.jpg



100_4185.jpg






View from inside the firebox shows that a little more than half of that communication hole between chambers is now blocked off. Smoke and heat must go under the baffle plate.


100_4186.jpg





Cut a new oval hole for the chimney on the opposite end of the smoke chamber lid (patterned after the original one) and mounted the chimney over there, then made a sheet metal patch plate for the original hole.

100_4187.jpg



100_4188.jpg





Fired up the pit with the new mods to get all the new metal "seasoned" and to test out the mods.

100_4189.jpg





I noticed a huge improvement in temperature control-ability. I am easily able to maintain a uniform 225-250 degrees in the smoke chamber and the temperature across the chamber is much more uniform. The baffle plate gets pretty warm, especially on the left side nearer the firebox, which will add radiant heat from below on the (now) cooler side of the smoke chamber. I'll be adding a rectangular water / drip pan on top of the baffle plate when in use to act as a heat sink and also give off some moisture to the smoke.



I have a few mods left to make to get this thing really ready to cook. I still need to extend the chimney pipe on the inside downward to nearer the grille height. This will help capture the hotter smoke in the upper part of the chamber rather than allowing it to escape, and vent the cooler smoke at the grille level. This is a common mod for any smoker.

I also plan on buying some high temp sealant/cement of some kind (maybe just use JB Weld) and plug up most of the leaks in the smoke chamber. Air leaks in the firebox are no big deal. You have to have air in there to burn the charcoal and wood anyway. But air leaks in the smoke chamber are causing it to cool too much and require more charcoal and wood to be burnt. I'll also be making some sort of a gasket for the smoke chamber lid, for the same reason.


I haven't cooked a thing on this little smoker, but I'm already having fun messing around with it.
wink.png


 
Cool, a hot-rodded grill, all you need is a nice flame paint job. Now that you have the equipment, where are you going to source the guests of honor on which you will be performing your magic smoke? I'm thinking about a ride over to that hawg famah (Colby?) in Newbury...

 
Great mods to your smoker Fred. More ambition that I have and I'm an engineer. :) I guess that means I'm lazy. I went through 3 other smokers before I settled on mine.

 
This is exactly what I was going to suggest. The more you can seal up the smoker as a whole and control where and how much air is coming and going will greatly aid in the control of the temperature.

One other thing you might do is consider cutting some holes in your baffle, and then using other metal to cover or uncover as tuning plates. Then you can adjust where your heat is for what you are cooking depending on how you open the holes in the baffle plate.

 
One other thing you might do is consider cutting some holes in your baffle, and then using other metal to cover or uncover as tuning plates. Then you can adjust where your heat is for what you are cooking depending on how you open the holes in the baffle plate.
That was exactly what I was going to do if I didn't move the chimney and make it into a reverse flow. Now that I have it might "short circuit" the smoke flow and make the far end too cool and smoke free.

Oh, one more little "option" I forgot to mention. I ordered up a low pressure propane burner head (King Kooker) and LP gas line/regulator. I am planning on trying to substitute the propane for the charcoal. I'll use a small cast iron fry pan for holding wood chunks and chips for the smoke. The point to the propane would be better heat regulation. If it doesn't work out, those parts will always find a welcome home down in the Basement Brewery.
wink.png


As for guests of honor I'm planning on doing another brisket (a whole one this time) this weekend. Our local butcher shop (Mr Steer) is running a special on whole briskets, and their meat is usually pretty spectacular. To me, good brisket is the epitome of the BBQ art. If I can master turning those out I'll be one happy camper.

PS - Thanks for the tip on the felt gasket, Scott. I wonder, is that some sort of flame resistant felt or do you think the regular felt weatherstrip stuff would work?

 
Last edited by a moderator:
I wish you well in your gas endevor Fred. I found the regulator knob on a gas rig to be too coarse for the fine adjusting I needed. I would tweek, wait, tweek, wait, tweek, wait...nothing. Then I would tweek and BOOM! The temp shoots up 10 degrees. I attribute it to the insides being sticky. I tried over rotating and backing it off. Still no luck for me.

I have no idea if that is "special" felt or not. Worse case scenario is you light some felt on fire.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
Stock up on wide aluminum foil. It can be your friend in getting brisket and ribs tender once the smoke has done its thing. I am really impressed with the mods you did. I had an offset unit like that and didn't get as nice of a baffle in there. I gave up on it and went to a Kamodo style.

 
Top