Tested them out this week. In the dry they are definitely warmer than my Teknic Winter and waterproof gloves.
In the wet, well it rained about an inch today, I was only out in the heaviest of it for an hour and 15, these gloves are not waterproof, ummm no sir not one bit. Hands were quite damp and the whole glove was soggy like a wet dog.
My Teknics in comparison had kept my hands completely dry when I rode a couple hours in three quarters of an inch precipitation.
So for the price they are great dry Winter gloves, but don't count on them to keep your hands dry in the wet.