It really should be thought of (and presented by them) as a "Best Practice" kind of thing.
The problem is, it should be presented as a "Best Practice" kind of thing
FOR NEW RIDERS! In my somewhat limited experience, there are a LOT of MSF RiderCoaches who have been teaching the same thing for a LONG time and apparently don't realize there are several ways to skin a cat. Especially for 'experienced' riders. I also really wonder how many of these VERY experienced RiderCoaches (who are in the motorcycle training business) have taken any advanced motorcycle training themselves where they may have actually learned some alternative ways of doing things for experienced riders and the reasoning behind it.
Sorry, off my pulpit. Just some things I have observed over the years, and especially over the last 6 months since I have become an MSF RiderCoach myself, and more recently, while working on becoming a Lee Parks' Total Control instructor.
Completely Agree Skootie. When teaching the Experienced Rider Course I just explain why the MSF recommends something, then it's up to them to go ahead and do it or not. But new riders in the BRC they want them to follow those specific things. I still find the time to explain why though, as it usually helps for them to remember.
Have seen the same thing with fellow rider coaches, from teaching in 4 different States now. Some RC's have been so new to riding and being an RC (1 Sponsor rushed this chick through everything cause he was into her), that all they know to do is exactly what the book says, they didn't even know why. Was told that the first time this chick demo'd the straightening than braking in a curve, she sent herself over the handlebars. True story.
Another RC (had been for 8 years) rode with the Sponsor and another RC to Deals Gap. On the very first run through, she crashed and just about totaled the bike. That was the end of the trip, they got her bike to stop leaking oil and rode straight back home. I asked her what went wrong in the corner? She said she didn't know. This is an RC I remind you, one that teaches Cornering!! Hey we can all make a mistake, but at least be very very aware of the fact you came in too hot for the corner, or else yer destined to keep making the same mistake over and over...
I'm getting signed up for the Advanced Rider Course and Total Control. The guy who teaches the ARC told me though that Emergency Braking and Swerving don't change, they are the same as we teach in the other classes. The Cornering is more advanced as Trail Braking is introduced.
Getting back to yer point, yeah many RC's seem to get carried away with telling other riders what to do. Most of them I think the intentions are good. Some of those I don't think even know why they are saying what they say, only because the MSF told them to. It's kind of sad for sure.
Hey Congrats on being an RC
We probably work for the same Sponsor