4-5mph slower with better gearing?
Sucks if Yamaha is going backwards. That would be reminiscent of the '02+ VFR 800! Ouch. I've also heard a 30lb weight gain. On the other hand, 4-5 slower translates to 151-152mph top speed - probably never notice! IMO top speed is less of a question than 1) roll-on numbers 2) quarter mile times. If those show a slip, that'd be bad...
I think acceleration (0-60 and 1/4 mile) has to be slower. The bike gained 30 pounds, and they increased the final drive gearing 5-6% in order to reduce the buzz cruising at 70mph in 5th.
I think a better solution would be to go to a lower than 1st generation gearing on 1-5 and add an overdrive. One of my complaints (and boy do I wish I posted this somewhere while Yamaha was gathering customer feedback for the '06) was that 1st is too tall for creaping along at idle in gridlock. My other bikes have a much lower first gear, and they are a lot easier to ride at very low speeds because I rarely have to slip the clutch.
I think the original decision to go with a 5-speed tranny was all about cost versus good 0-60 numbers. The FJR is plenty powerful to deal with the tall 1st gear. Gearing that tall allows blasting to 61mph without a shift. This gives great 0-60 times, and as a result sells more motorcycles. If Yamaha went with a more practical 1st, a shift would be needed before 60, and the performance figures would suffer.
Long story short, my wants:
6 speed tranny with lower 1-5 gearing and O/D
Better alternator
More horsepower
Higher redline
I really liked the idea above about a touring trunk that mounts on the rear seat.
Factory throttle lock or cruise control
Better on-the-fly adjustability of heat management louvers than on the '06 (the '06 seems to require a tool to change the aperature of the side vents)
Better small-input throttle/FI response (Honda ST1300 wins here)
More color choices
NO PDP!
MUCH BETTER GROUND CLEARANCE - PEGS SCRAPE WAY EARLY
Battery moved to much lower position than current location
Bags that can be set to allow keyless opening via pushbutton or keyed opening (I hate having to shut the bike down to open the case when I'm on a trip)
Lastly - complete invincibility with respect to deer