I'll stick my big nose where it probably doesn't belong. Better judgment hasn't stopped me before....
This debate is one of the things that really shortens my tongue in my conversations with some other riders. Rather than inadvertently start a HEATED debate and have people get all butt hurt, I mostly choose to bite my tongue. And yet, here I am....
The fact is, that most of those people don't have any idea what they are talking about.
There does not exist in this world a liter motorcycle built either yesterday or today that is short in the power department when it comes down to REAL WORLD riding. It's ridiculous, really, to debate and discuss the difference between a bike that runs 11.48 in the quarter mile, and another that runs 11.27, and still another that runs 10.85. On the track, that means the difference between 1st and 10th. On the streets, it doesn't mean a flipping thing. Quite frankly, they are all stupid fast and way more than 99% of their owners will ever be able to use. Unless of course your riding dream is to be posted on Youtube running away from the police, and if that is the case, you don't need an FJR - you need a good lawyer and a **** LOAD of money.
What you want is a bike that will respond nicely to the input you give it for the riding that you like to do. The FJR works for me because I can load it like a Sherpa, set the cruise at 75 (or 85 in some cases) with all of my crap loaded, and the motor is chugging along smoothly at 4000-ish rpm. And then at the twisties, I can unload it, forget about 1st, 4th, and 5th gear, and go have some (relative) fun in the curves with the torque monster. And when I'm on that two lane highway in the remote country side, sitting behind 4 or 5 tractors, trucks, Sunday drivers, little 'ole ladies coming home from church, and/or any combination of the sort, I can downshift 2 gears, light the candle, merge back into my lane at about a buck fifteen, and the resume my ride. And of course, every once in a while, when I'm feeling a bit squid-ish, I can run her up through a couple of gears and get that out of my system.
After you ride for more than 100,000 miles, you start to realize precisely what it is you want in a motorcycle. And I dare state that "straight line performance" doesn't even make the top 5 on that list. I do try to be patient with others, but sometimes it's difficult.
ReRose - this isn't meant to be insulting toward you (or anyone else). You are entitled to your opinion, and I respect you for it. Its just that mature sport touring riders usually don't participate in pissing matches. Some things just speak for themselves.