Well, you guys were right. We were very busy with the whole Brisket BBQ, face stuffing, and family fun, to be posting fotos. I was so wrapped up in everything that I didn't get any decent cut meat shots. That and it turned out a bit underwhelming.
The cook did not go as I had planned. The water bath had too much water in it, or too much suface area, and It turned the whole thing into a giant steam bath. The outside of the meat was not darkening into the wonderful bark that I covet, so when it reached the 160F stall I opened up the drum and removed the water pan altogether and put the meat back on flipped with the fat side down over the semi-direct heat of the drum. I don't think I'd bother with the water pan again. Oh well, I'm only out ~ 4 bucks as the extra grille will come in handy in some other ways. like expanding my ribs capacity.
I did manage to snap some phone pics of the (nearly) finished brisket... Here's Angus at around 6pm, after ~12 hours of smoking at 220-230F.
The probe (in the tip end) was only at around 170F, but when I stuck a second thermometer probe into the thickest section of the flat that was already up to 185F. So right after this photo I cut and harvested the flat half and left the (much fattier) tip on the smoker to finish on its own.
After another good hour of resting in my faux cambrio (a small cooler with some towels wrapped around the foil wrapped meat) and several adult libations
, I plumb forgot to take any fud Pr0n shots when I sliced up the meat. The smoke ring was thin, substandard IMO, and the bark was not magnificent, which I attribute to the steaming vs smoking. The flat tasted fine, and was relatively tender, but not as much smoke flavor as what I was expecting. The rub did make the bark that was there quite tasty and peppery (both black and cayenne), but it still needed some help with BBQ sauce (I prefer Stubbs Spicy)
A couple of hours later with the tip at 190F (I was shooting for 195) I pulled it and wrapped it and tossed it in the faux cambrio. The extra time seems to have improved the bark, but I'll be warming it on the gas grille whenever we decide to attack that half, so it will firm up the bark even more.
All in all, I would declare smoking a full brisket to just be too much of a PITA (and expense) to bother with it again. I might be tempted to do one end or the other again, but doing the whole thing complicates things greatly. I'll also skip the steam bath in the future, and just work on keeping my temps low and slow to avoid drying out the meat.
While the meat was good, it did not live up to my high expectations (or high expense) as compared to the ribs, poultry, and pork shoulder that I've done in the past. I hope other folks have more complete successes with their holiday weekend 'que than we did.