I rented an ST1300 for a few days to see how I would like it in 2006 with the intention of selling/trading my ST1100 at that time. I ended up keeping the 1100 for two more years. I was not yet ready at admit that a Yamaha could be a viable option, I didn't want a Gold Wing, and the ST1300 just didn't offer enough better compared to the ST1100 to convince me to go that route. I generally have 3 to 5 bikes in the garage, and I am a fickle guy, so stuff moves in and out all the time. The ST1100 was great for its day. The ST1300 just didn't impress me as much for its day.
I have been considering a BMW K1200GT for purchase at the end of the current riding season. I love my 07 K1200Rsport, and since the K1200GT shares the same engine with slightly different tuning, it seemed like a natural choice for me.
I came upon a leftover 06 FJR1300AE in early June, and I took a test ride. I bought the bike and have been very happy with it during the first 2000 miles. I can honestly say that the FJR has pushed any thoughts about picking up a leftover 08 K1200GT far out to the back burner... and perhaps even off the stove.
Compared to the ST1300, the FJR is lighter, more powerful, and easier for basic maintenance (like oil and filter changes). It feels less like a tank. Its no sport bike in spite of assertions you will hear to the contrary... but it is a heck of a lot more sporty than either of the STs.
I had to get a Sargent seat for it to be comfortable on longer rides, but I had a Corbin on my ST1100, and probably would have gone to an aftermarket seat on an ST1300 too after my experience with the rental unit.
You might want to try a rental and see what you think? I'm sold on the FJR and expect it to be my saddlebag bike for at least a couple of years, maybe longer. Its not giving me any reasons to want something else right now, and that's unusual for me. Hey - the best bike is always the next bike
.