This is a very subjective topic – so many factors go into what works and feels good for a specific rider and bike setup in their geographic area. One aspect that is not captured in the poll questions is suspension set up – is it OEM or aftermarket? Have both ends been upgraded or only the rear (or front)? Is the suspension serviced regularly?
The follow is my opinion based on my experiences.
My tire choice falls into two categories – under 3500 miles, or over 3500 miles. My FJR (2009) has an Ohlins YA-707 rear shock/spring and re-valved forks with aftermarket springs up front. The front suspension is serviced (fluid flush and fill) annually, the rear Ohlins goes in every 2 years.
For trips and riding where traction is weighted more than tread life (local and short trips), my current go to is the Continental Road Attack 2 GT front and rear. This tire will return a solid 4k for me. It should be noted that the Road Attack 2 c-spec is NOT the same tire as the GT; this was made painfully clear on our EOM trip this year. The RA2 rear was bald shoulder to shoulder at 2,275 miles when we rolled into Ironpony in Columbus. Traction was beyond outstanding, but this is not a FJR tire, and Continental has noted that the GT is made for heavier sport touring bikes.
For anything more than 4k miles, I like the Metzeler Z8 b-spec front and rear. This setup has will reliably return 6800-7k miles from the rear. These tires maintain their profile very well (for me); this tire exhibits the least amount of handling deterioration over its life out of any other tire I’ve run. Traction is acceptable, but reduced as compared to my short range tire selection.
The plan for 2014 is to run a PR2 rear paired with a Pilot Power (or PP 2CT) front. The PR2 was what I ended up with when we had the rear changed on the way home from EOM. This is a very subjective topic – so many factors go into what works and feels good for a specific rider and bike setup in their geographic area. One aspect that is not captured in the poll questions is suspension set up – is it OEM or aftermarket? Have both ends been upgraded or only the rear (or front)? Is the suspension serviced regularly?