I don't know what it is about HD, I guess because they have been so successful with new/old bikes they have stuck with that and not "moved on".
I can answer that. For all their bluster and macho bombast, HD is not a motorcycle company. They're a marketing company, a lifestyle company. They market a particular image, and their business model requires them to spend the least amount of money possible on hardware to create a product that people can buy that fits the image they sell. That's why they continue to simply rebundle old technology in different combinations, and it's why when the economy tanked, their sales dropped as much as they did, much more than the sales of other brands dropped: because no one buys an HD for any reason other than to fit into the Harley-lifestyle fantasy (well, a very small number of people buy Harleys for touring). But no one buys a Harley for sport-riding or dirt-riding or the joy of cutting-edge technoloty or simple, low-cost commuting or sport-touring.
Well, maybe so, but altho this downslide has hurt HD as well, they're doing better than the rest. Alot of us are scratching our heads at dumping Buell and MV, but I guess they just figured to cut costs and that was the easiest way. There are HD dealers everywhere, and around here, they have events all the time. Most weekends you can stop by and they've got food/drinks, a band/music, and something else going on that draws folks in, both the curious and the faithful. They may be just a marketing company, but isn't that what sells? HD has, afterall, been around since 1903 and have been through some tremendous ups and downs, but survived regardless, and are doing it now with decades old technology.
If you think about it, HD's are so simple from a manufacturing and servicing view. They basically only have 3 drivetrains - VRod, Sportster, and Big Twin. BT's are in 3 different chassis, and one chassis each for the other two. They snaz 'em up with paint, wheels, and other doodads, but basically there's not that many differences. Easy for a dealer in all aspects. And, their customers don't really demand big advances in technology like the other manufacturers do.
I like the small shops as many seem to be staffed by folks that really like bikes. The HD shops are - from what I've seen - big and "professional"; maybe the sales guys only jumped in for the $$ and "lifestyle", but the dealers have everything. My little Yam-Suz shop is limited (still don't have a '10 FJR on the floor) and some models have been there for an extended period. My '09A had been there for ~9 months I believe. Marketing is where it's at, esp in a slow market I'd think.
I guess it's like the local hardware store being put on hard times by the new Lowe's or Home Depot that opened in town; the big japanese motorcycle shops have an absolutely huge line of products they have to carry, and most have multiple brands. Down here, at the little shop I bought mine from, I think their mainstay are 4 wheelers; it's what keeps them in business.
I think we need to get the address for the FJR program manager and send some mail - the old fashioned type. Do 'em like you would a politician when they are considering some bill. Tell 'em that we know money is tight, but for minimum output they could improve the Gen 2 with a ground spider fix, a larger alternator, and standard or optional cruise. The extra trans gear would probably take "too much" development cash - who knows, but they could bump displacement pretty easy I'd think with either/both bore/stroke. You know, suggest things that cost little development money but would make some great changes for those of us that like 'em, and those that are shopping for the best bike/value. Maybe a better suspension they could adapt from the R1 - I don't know - but stuff like that.
Just a thought - always dangerous for me...